Publication Process

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen follows a structured editorial process designed to ensure the quality, integrity, and timeliness of all published articles. The following stages apply to all submitted manuscripts. The period stated at each stage is the standard the editorial office undertakes to meet, and authors are entitled to enquire about the progress of their manuscript once a stated period has elapsed.

Stage 1: Submission
Authors submit their manuscript via the OJS platform at ojs.institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id/index.php/manthano, together with the similarity report, the reporting guideline checklist where applicable, and ethics documentation where the research involves human participants.

Because the journal operates a double-blind review process, the version sent to reviewers must carry no information identifying the authors. Authors may satisfy this requirement by either of two methods, and both are equally acceptable:

Method 1: Single manuscript. Authors submit one complete manuscript containing all author names, affiliations, and acknowledgements in the ordinary way. The editorial office prepares the anonymised version before the manuscript enters review, removing author names, affiliations, corresponding author details, acknowledgements, funding information, the institutional name in ethics approval statements, and the author details recorded in the file properties.

Method 2: Two versions. Authors submit a blinded manuscript from which all identifying information has already been removed, together with a full unblinded version uploaded as a supplementary file.

Under either method, authors remain responsible for identifying information embedded in the body of the text, which the editorial office cannot reliably detect. This includes self-citations phrased so as to reveal authorship, references to the authors’ own institution in the research setting or method, and acknowledgement of individuals in a way that identifies the research team. Authors are asked to phrase such references in the third person.

The editorial office sends an acknowledgement of receipt within three (3) working days.

Stage 2: Initial Editorial Check
Upon receipt, the editorial office conducts an initial check to assess whether the manuscript falls within the journal’s focus and scope, meets the formatting and structural requirements of the Author Guidelines, includes all compulsory supplementary files, and does not exceed the maximum similarity index of 20 per cent excluding the reference list.

Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements are returned to the authors for correction before proceeding to review. Manuscripts that fall outside the scope of the journal are declined at this stage, with reasons. This stage is completed within fourteen (14) days of submission.

Stage 3: Double-Blind Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass the initial check are assigned to a minimum of two (2) independent reviewers with relevant expertise. The identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed throughout. The criteria by which manuscripts are assessed, and the policy governing reviewer selection, are set out on the Peer Review Process page.

Reviewers are asked to submit their report within twenty-eight (28) days of accepting the invitation. A reviewer who has not responded within fourteen (14) days of invitation is replaced. In the light of the reviewer reports, the editor communicates one of four decisions to the authors: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.

This stage ordinarily takes four (4) to six (6) weeks, and no longer than eight (8) weeks where a third reviewer is appointed. Manuscripts reporting empirical field research are placed in a fast-track review stream and receive an initial editorial decision within four (4) weeks of a completed submission.

Stage 4: Revision
Authors who receive a revision decision must submit a revised manuscript together with a point-by-point response letter addressing each reviewer comment, including an explanation where a comment has not been adopted.

Minor revisions are to be returned within fourteen (14) days, major revisions within twenty-eight (28) days. An extension may be requested in writing before the deadline falls due.

Revised manuscripts are assessed within fourteen (14) days of receipt and may be returned to the original reviewers for re-evaluation, in which case a further twenty-one (21) days is allowed. A manuscript may undergo more than one round of revision. Revisions submitted more than sixty (60) days after the decision letter are treated as new submissions.

Stage 5: Final Decision and Acceptance
Once the revised manuscript has been assessed and approved by the editor, a formal acceptance letter is issued within seven (7) working days. Authors are notified of the issue in which the article is expected to appear.

The invoice for the Article Processing Charge is issued at this point; the amount, the conditions, and the waiver procedure are stated on the Article Processing Charge page. The charge is never levied before acceptance and has no bearing on the editorial decision.

Stage 6: Copyediting and Proofreading
Accepted manuscripts undergo copyediting for language, formatting, and consistency with the journal’s style requirements. The proof is sent to the corresponding author within fourteen (14) days of acceptance, and the approved proof must be returned within three (3) working days.

Changes at this stage are limited to the correction of typographical errors and factual inaccuracies. Substantial revision of content is not permitted after acceptance. Where a proof is not returned within seven (7) days, the editorial office proceeds with the version prepared by the copyeditor.

Stage 7: Publication
Following proof approval and receipt of the Article Processing Charge, the article is assigned a DOI, formatted for online publication, and published in the current issue at ojs.institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id/index.php/manthano. Articles are published as a complete issue on 31 March and 30 September. All published articles are immediately and permanently available open access under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International licence.

Publication Schedule
Manthano publishes two (2) issues each year, in March and September. Manuscripts intended for the March issue should be submitted by 31 December of the preceding year, and manuscripts intended for the September issue by 30 June. Manuscripts submitted after these dates are considered for the following issue.

The entire publication process, from initial submission to final publication, takes a minimum of three (3) months. Authors are encouraged to submit well in advance of the target issue.

Service Standards

The editorial office undertakes to meet the following standards:

  1. Acknowledgement of receipt within three (3) working days of submission
  2. Outcome of the initial editorial check within fourteen (14) days of submission
  3. Reviewer reports and an editorial decision within six (6) weeks of the manuscript entering review, or eight (8) weeks where a third reviewer is appointed
  4. An initial decision within four (4) weeks for manuscripts reporting empirical field research
  5. Assessment of a revised manuscript within fourteen (14) days of receipt
  6. A formal acceptance letter within seven (7) working days of final approval
  7. A proof within fourteen (14) days of acceptance
  8. A substantive reply to any author enquiry within five (5) working days

Where a stated period has elapsed without communication, authors are invited to contact the editorial office at lppm@institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id, quoting the submission number. An enquiry about the progress of a manuscript carries no disadvantage of any kind.

Rights of Authors
Authors are entitled to be informed of the status of their manuscript at every stage; to receive the anonymised reviewer comments in full together with any decision other than a desk rejection; to receive reasons for a decision to decline a manuscript; to respond to reviewer comments, including by declining to adopt them where the response gives grounds; to appeal a decision in writing within fourteen (14) days, as set out on the Peer Review Process page; to apply for a waiver of the Article Processing Charge without prejudice to the editorial outcome; and to retain copyright in their work under the terms stated on the Copyright and License page.

Withdrawal
A manuscript may be withdrawn at any time before the editorial decision is issued, by written request from the corresponding author, without charge or penalty.

Withdrawal after a manuscript has been reviewed is strongly discouraged, since reviewers have committed unpaid scholarly labour to it, and a request at that stage must state the reason. A manuscript may not be withdrawn after an acceptance letter has been issued, except where the authors identify an error that renders the findings unreliable, in which case the editorial office will treat the matter under the Correction and Retraction policy. Authors who withdraw an accepted manuscript without such grounds may be refused consideration of further submissions for a period of twelve (12) months.