Authorship Criteria

Manthano: Journal of Christian Education applies the authorship criteria recommended by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) and endorsed by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). This page expands the authorship provisions stated in the journal’s Publication Ethics and Author Guidelines.

Criteria for Authorship

Authorship is restricted to individuals who meet all four of the following conditions:

  1. A substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data
  2. Drafting the manuscript or revising it critically for important intellectual content
  3. Final approval of the version submitted for publication
  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including the accuracy and integrity of any part of it

Meeting one or two of these conditions does not establish authorship. Individuals who have contributed to the research but do not meet all four must be named in the Acknowledgements with their permission, with the nature of their contribution stated. This includes those who provided funding, administrative support, technical assistance, language editing, or general supervision of the research group.

Order of Authors and the Corresponding Author

The order of authors is determined by the authors themselves and must be agreed by all of them before submission. The editorial office does not arbitrate the sequence of names.

Each manuscript must designate one corresponding author, who is responsible for communication with the editorial office, for confirming that every listed author has read and approved the submission, for supplying complete author metadata including ORCID identifiers, for coordinating responses to reviewer comments, and for returning the proof within the stated deadline. The corresponding author acts on behalf of all co-authors and remains available to respond to queries after publication.

Contributorship Statement

Every manuscript must include an Author Contributions statement in the Acknowledgements section, using the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) framework to describe the specific role of each author, as required by the Author Guidelines. The statement must correspond to the authorship criteria above: a listed author whose stated contribution does not meet the four conditions will be queried by the editorial office before the manuscript proceeds.

ORCID

Each listed author must hold an active and publicly accessible ORCID iD. Submissions may be returned where an ORCID profile is missing, incomplete, or set to private.

Changes to Authorship

Any addition, removal, or reordering of authors after submission requires a written request from the corresponding author stating the reason for the change, together with written confirmation of agreement from all authors, including the author being added or removed. Requests received after acceptance will be considered only in exceptional circumstances and will delay publication. Where a change is warranted after publication, the journal will issue a correction notice linked to the original article.

Prohibited Practices

The following practices are prohibited and are treated as research misconduct under the journal’s policy on allegations of research misconduct:

  1. Ghost authorship, in which a person who meets the authorship criteria is omitted from the list
  2. Gift, guest, or honorary authorship, in which a person who does not meet the criteria is listed
  3. The inclusion of a supervisor, head of department, institutional leader, or senior colleague solely on grounds of position, seniority, or the provision of facilities
  4. The sale or purchase of authorship positions, and the use of paper mills or any third-party service that supplies authorship for payment
  5. The addition of an author in order to satisfy an institutional, promotional, or funding requirement unrelated to their contribution

Artificial Intelligence

AI and AI-assisted technologies cannot be listed as authors, since they cannot take responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, or originality of the work, and cannot be held accountable for it. Any use of such tools must be disclosed in the Acknowledgements in accordance with the journal’s AI Policy, naming the tool, the purpose of its use, and confirming that the authors have reviewed and verified all resulting content. Responsibility for every statement in the manuscript rests with the human authors.

Authorship Disputes

Disputes concerning authorship are handled in accordance with the relevant COPE flowcharts. The editorial office does not adjudicate the substance of a dispute, since it has no access to the circumstances in which the research was conducted. Where a dispute arises, processing of the manuscript is suspended and the matter is referred to the authors’ institutions for resolution. No manuscript will be published, and no published article will be amended, while an authorship dispute remains unresolved.