Allegation of Research Misconduct

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen investigates every allegation of research misconduct concerning a manuscript under consideration or an article already published, following the flowcharts issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Scope
Research misconduct, for the purposes of this policy, includes:

  1. Fabrication of data, results, participants, interviews, or sources
  2. Falsification or selective manipulation of data, images, figures, or quotations, including the misrepresentation of a cited author’s position
  3. Plagiarism and self-plagiarism, as defined on the journal’s Plagiarism page
  4. Duplicate or redundant submission and publication, including the submission of substantially the same work to more than one journal
  5. Citation manipulation, including coercive citation, gratuitous self-citation, and participation in citation cartels
  6. Undisclosed conflicts of interest, as defined on the journal’s Conflict of Interest page
  7. Breaches of research ethics governing human participants, including the absence of ethics approval or informed consent, and research conducted with minors or members of a congregation without appropriate safeguards
  8. Breaches of authorship integrity, including ghost, gift, and guest authorship, and the sale or purchase of authorship
  9. Fabrication of peer reviewer identities, contact details, or reviewer reports
  10. Submission of a false or manipulated similarity report
  11. Use of paper mills or any third-party service supplying manuscripts, data, or authorship for payment
  12. Undisclosed use of AI-assisted technologies in a manner contrary to the journal’s AI Policy

Honest error and genuine differences of scholarly or theological interpretation do not constitute misconduct. A manuscript whose argument an editor or reviewer finds unpersuasive is rejected on scholarly grounds, not investigated under this policy.

Making an Allegation
Allegations may be made by readers, reviewers, editors, authors, or institutions, and should be addressed in writing to the editorial office at lppm@institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id.

An allegation should identify the manuscript or published article concerned, describe the specific concern, and provide supporting evidence, such as the source of the allegedly plagiarised text, the publication in which the work previously appeared, or the data in question. A general expression of suspicion without evidence cannot be investigated.

The identity of the person raising the concern is treated as confidential and will not be disclosed to the authors without that person’s consent. Anonymous allegations are considered where the evidence supplied is sufficient to be assessed on its own merits, since those closest to research misconduct are often those least able to report it openly. Allegations made in bad faith, or for the purpose of harassment, retaliation, or academic rivalry, will not be pursued.

Investigation
The editorial office acknowledges receipt of an allegation within five working days.

The Editor-in-Chief conducts an initial assessment to determine whether the concern is substantive. Where it is not, the matter is closed and the person raising it is informed with reasons.

Where the concern is substantive, the corresponding author is informed of the allegation in full and invited to respond in writing within fourteen days. The authors may be asked to supply raw data, field notes, transcripts, ethics documentation, permissions, or the original versions of figures. Failure to respond within the period allowed, or refusal to supply evidence within the authors’ control, will be taken into account in reaching a conclusion.

The editorial office may consult subject experts, members of the reviewer board, or specialists in research integrity, and may seek technical verification of text, images, or data. Where the authors are affiliated to an institution, the editorial office may refer the matter to that institution, which is ordinarily better placed than a journal to investigate the conduct of research.

All parties are treated as acting in good faith until the evidence establishes otherwise. The investigation is conducted confidentially, and no public statement is made while it is in progress.

Outcomes
Where an allegation is not substantiated, the matter is closed and all parties are informed in writing. No record of an unsubstantiated allegation is attached to the manuscript or to the authors.

Where misconduct is established in a manuscript under consideration, the manuscript is rejected and the decision is recorded in the editorial system.

Where misconduct is established in a published article, the journal issues a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction, as the severity of the case requires, in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy.

In serious cases the editorial office notifies the authors’ institutions and, where applicable, the funder of the research, and may impose a ban on further submissions by the authors concerned for a period of up to three years. Where an article is retracted for established misconduct, the ban applies to all authors who were aware of it.

Appeals
Authors may appeal a finding of misconduct in writing within fourteen days of being notified, setting out the specific grounds. Appeals are considered by the Editor-in-Chief together with a member of the editorial board who took no part in the original investigation. The decision on an appeal is final.

Allegations Concerning Editors
Where an allegation concerns a member of the editorial board, the editor named takes no part in any stage of the process and is removed from the editorial system for the duration of the investigation.

Where an allegation concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the investigation is conducted by the Chair of the Lembaga Penelitian dan Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat (LPPM) of Institut Agama Kristen REAL Batam, who may appoint an external reviewer with no connection to the journal. The outcome is reported to the publisher and acted upon under this policy in the same manner as an allegation concerning any other party.