Manuscript Types

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen publishes three categories of manuscript. All categories are subject to the same double-blind peer review process, the same ethical requirements, and the same formatting standards set out in the Author Guidelines. The word counts stated below exclude the abstract, tables, figures, and reference list.

Original Research

Original Research articles report novel empirical or theoretical findings that make a substantive contribution to knowledge in Christian Religious Education, and are between 5,000 and 8,000 words. Manuscripts in this category follow the full structure of Title, Abstract and Keywords, Introduction, Research Method, Results and Discussion, Conclusion, Acknowledgements, and References. Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-method designs are equally welcome, provided the methodology is rigorous, transparent, and appropriate to the research question.

Authors must apply the reporting guideline appropriate to the study design, such as CONSORT for randomised trials, STROBE for observational studies, or COREQ for qualitative research, and submit the completed checklist as a supplementary file. Research involving human participants requires ethics approval as stated in the Author Guidelines. A maximum of seven illustrations is permitted. Manuscripts in this category that report empirical field research collecting primary data from churches, schools, faith communities, or households are placed in the journal’s fast-track review stream and receive an initial editorial decision within four weeks of a completed submission.

Review Articles

Review Articles offer a comprehensive and critical synthesis of existing scholarship on a defined topic within the journal’s scope, and are between 4,000 and 6,000 words. In place of a Research Method section, the manuscript must state the review protocol: the research question guiding the review, the databases consulted, the search terms used, the period covered, and the criteria by which sources were included or excluded. Systematic, scoping, and integrative reviews are all accepted, and authors of systematic reviews are encouraged to follow PRISMA reporting.

A review must advance a critical argument. A manuscript that summarises prior literature without analysing it, without identifying a knowledge gap, or without setting out an agenda for further research will be returned to the authors without external review.

Conceptual and Theological Studies

Conceptual and Theological Studies present original arguments grounded in biblical, systematic, historical, or practical theology, and are between 5,000 and 7,000 words. In place of a Research Method section, these manuscripts must include a Theoretical Framework section stating the theological tradition or philosophical position from which the authors write, the analytical or interpretive method applied, whether exegetical, historical-critical, hermeneutical, phenomenological, or comparative, and the primary sources on which the argument rests. This requirement allows reviewers to assess the methodological rigour of a non-empirical argument on its own terms rather than by the standards of empirical enquiry.

Manuscripts in this category must make their implications for educational practice explicit. A theological argument that does not connect to the formation of learners, the work of teachers, the life of the church, or the design of curriculum falls outside the scope of the journal, however well constructed it may be.

Requirements Common to All Categories

  1. Written in British English following Oxford English Dictionary conventions
  2. Title of no more than 14 words, in title case, without abbreviations
  3. Abstracts of no more than 200 words in both English and Indonesian, each closing with a labelled Contribution statement of no more than 50 words
  4. Between five and eight keywords, separated by semicolons
  5. References in APA 7th edition, numbering between 20 and 60, with all DOIs verified before submission
  6. An active and publicly accessible ORCID iD for every listed author
  7. A similarity index of no more than 20 per cent, excluding the reference list, accompanied by a similarity report
  8. All declarations required by the Author Guidelines, covering competing interests, author contributions under CRediT, funding, data availability, ethical considerations, the disclaimer, and the use of AI-assisted technologies
  9. Two versions of the manuscript at submission: a blinded version with all identifying information removed, and a full unblinded version uploaded as a supplementary file

Categories Not Currently Accepted

The journal does not publish book reviews, editorials, letters to the editor, conference abstracts, short communications, opinion pieces, sermons, devotional material, or institutional reports. Coursework and seminar papers are not accepted in the form in which they were submitted for assessment. Manuscripts drawn from a thesis or dissertation are welcome, provided the work has been substantially rewritten for journal publication, meets the requirements of one of the three categories above, and cites the thesis in the Acknowledgements.

Selecting a Category

Authors must state the intended category in the cover letter at submission. Where the content, structure, or length of a manuscript makes a different category more appropriate, the editorial office may reassign it and will notify the corresponding author, with reasons, before the manuscript is sent for review. Reassignment is an editorial judgement about the form of the manuscript and carries no implication about its quality.