Correction and Retraction

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen maintains the integrity of the scholarly record in accordance with the retraction guidelines issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Two principles govern this policy. First, a published article is permanent: it is never removed from the journal’s website, except in the narrow circumstances set out below. Second, a published article is never altered silently. Every change to the scholarly record is announced in a notice that is published separately, carries its own DOI, and is linked in both directions with the article concerned.

Correction
A correction notice is issued where a published article contains an error that affects the record or the interpretation of the work, but does not undermine its findings or conclusions. Grounds for correction include:

  1. Errors in data, calculations, tables, or figures that do not alter the conclusions
  2. Errors in the names, affiliations, or ORCID identifiers of authors
  3. Changes to authorship agreed under the Authorship Criteria policy
  4. Omitted or inaccurate funding information, ethics approval details, or competing interest declarations
  5. Errors in references or citations that misattribute a source
  6. Omission of required acknowledgement of a contributor or permission holder

A correction may be requested by the authors or initiated by the editorial office. The notice is published in the current issue, states precisely what was incorrect and what the correct position is, and is linked with the original article. The article itself is not reissued, and its pagination and DOI are unchanged.

Typographical errors that do not affect meaning are recorded in the correction notice where one is issued, and are not in themselves grounds for a notice.

Expression of Concern
An Expression of Concern is published where the editorial office has well-founded reason to doubt the integrity or reliability of a published article but is not yet in a position to reach a conclusion. This arises where an investigation under the Allegation of Research Misconduct policy remains in progress, where an institutional inquiry is under way and its outcome cannot be anticipated, where the authors have not responded to a substantive concern within the period allowed, or where the evidence available is insufficient to establish the matter either way.

The notice states the nature of the concern, makes clear that no finding has been reached, and is linked with the article. It is replaced by a correction, a retraction, or a notice of resolution once the matter concludes. An Expression of Concern is not a finding against the authors.

Retraction
An article is retracted where its findings can no longer be relied upon, or where its publication breached the ethical standards of the journal. Grounds for retraction include:

  1. Findings shown to be unreliable, whether as a result of research misconduct or of honest error
  2. Fabrication or falsification of data, sources, or results
  3. Plagiarism or self-plagiarism of a substantial part of the work
  4. Redundant or duplicate publication of the same work
  5. Research conducted without the required ethics approval or informed consent
  6. Undisclosed conflicts of interest material to the findings or their interpretation
  7. Falsified authorship, or authorship obtained by purchase
  8. Publication resulting from a compromised peer review process, including fabricated reviewer identities
  9. Production of the article by a paper mill or an equivalent third-party service
  10. Infringement of copyright or of a legal right of a third party

A retraction corrects the scholarly record. It does not of itself imply an intention to deceive on the part of any author, and the retraction notice distinguishes, where the evidence permits, between misconduct and honest error.

How a Retraction Is Effected
The retracted article remains available on the journal’s website. The PDF is watermarked as retracted on every page, the article landing page is prominently labelled as retracted, and the original text is left otherwise unchanged so that readers may see what was published.

A separate retraction notice is published in the current issue with its own DOI. The notice identifies the article in full, states who is retracting it and on what grounds, records the date of retraction, and indicates whether all authors agree with the retraction. Where the authors dissent, that is recorded. The notice is linked in both directions with the retracted article.

The editorial office informs the indexing and abstracting services in which the journal is listed, so that the retraction is reflected in Google Scholar, SINTA, Dimensions, Garuda, Scispace, and DOAJ.

Removal
An article is removed from public view only where its continued availability would constitute a clear legal risk to the journal or to a third party, where removal is required by a court order, where it would pose a serious risk to health, or where it contains personal data published in breach of the privacy of a research participant.

In such cases the article metadata, comprising title, authors, and DOI, remain published, and the landing page states that the article has been removed and the reason for removal in general terms.

Partial Retraction

Where a discrete and separable part of an article is unreliable but the remainder stands, the journal may issue a partial retraction identifying the affected section. Partial retraction is used sparingly, and only where the sound and unsound parts of the article can be clearly distinguished.

Requesting a Correction or Retraction
Requests may be made by the authors, by readers, or by an institution, and should be addressed in writing to the editorial office at lppm@institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id, identifying the article and stating the grounds with supporting evidence.

Where the request concerns a possible breach of publication ethics, it is investigated under the Allegation of Research Misconduct policy, and the authors are given the opportunity to respond before any notice is published. The editorial office acknowledges a request within five (5) working days and communicates the outcome in writing.

Authors who become aware of an error in their own published work are expected to notify the editorial office without delay. Prompt self-correction is regarded as consistent with scholarly integrity and carries no disadvantage to the authors.

Authority
The decision to issue a correction, an Expression of Concern, a retraction, or a removal rests with the Editor-in-Chief, who takes it independently of the publisher and of any institution to which the authors belong. Where the Editor-in-Chief is among the authors of the article concerned, the decision is taken by another member of the editorial board with no connection to the work. The decision is final.