Post-Publication Discussion

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen regards scholarly assessment as continuing after publication. Peer review engages two or three expert readers before an article appears; the readership that follows is far larger, and the journal provides the following channels through which it may engage with, question, and correct published work.

Scholarly Comment
Readers who wish to take issue with the argument, method, evidence, or interpretation of a published article may write to the editorial office at lppm@institutkristenrealbatam.ac.id, identifying the article and setting out the substance of the comment with supporting references.

The editorial office assesses whether the comment raises a point of scholarly substance. Where it does, the comment is forwarded to the corresponding author, who is invited to reply within twenty-eight (28) days. Where the exchange makes a meaningful contribution to the debate, the journal may publish the comment and the authors’ response together in a subsequent issue, each carrying its own DOI and linked with the original article. The authors of the original article are always given the opportunity to respond before a comment is published.

Comments are subject to editorial assessment and, where appropriate, to peer review. The journal is not obliged to publish every comment it receives, and a decision not to publish is communicated with reasons.

Standards of Discussion
Comments must address the scholarly content of the work: its evidence, its reasoning, its method, its use of sources, or its conclusions. The journal publishes theological scholarship, and disagreement over interpretation is a normal and welcome part of that enterprise.

Correspondence that attacks the authors personally, that impugns their faith, competence, or standing rather than their argument, that disparages a denomination, tradition, or community, or that is abusive, defamatory, or anonymous, will not be forwarded to the authors and will not be published. The editorial office does not act as a forum for doctrinal adjudication between traditions.

Concerns about Integrity
Where a reader’s concern bears not on the merits of an argument but on the integrity of the work, including suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or breaches of research ethics, it is not handled as scholarly comment. Such concerns are investigated under the Allegation of Research Misconduct policy and may result in a correction, an Expression of Concern, or a retraction under the Correction and Retraction policy.

Readers who are uncertain which channel applies are invited to write to the editorial office, which will direct the matter appropriately.

Errors of Fact
Readers who identify an error of fact in a published article, such as a misquotation, a misattributed source, an arithmetical error, or an inaccurate reference, may report it to the editorial office. Verified errors are corrected under the Correction and Retraction policy.

Author-Initiated Clarification
Authors who become aware of an error in their own published work, or who wish to clarify a point that has been widely misunderstood, are expected to notify the editorial office without delay. Self-reported errors are handled under the Correction and Retraction policy, and prompt self-correction is regarded as consistent with scholarly integrity rather than as a mark against the authors.

Discussion Beyond the Journal

All articles are published open access under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International licence and may be discussed, cited, reviewed, taught, translated, and criticised in any forum without permission from the journal, subject to proper attribution.

Articles are indexed in Google Scholar, SINTA, Dimensions, Garuda, Scispace, and DOAJ, and carry a DOI, so that citation of and response to a published article is traceable through those services. The journal does not moderate discussion hosted elsewhere and takes no position on it.

Record of Discussion
Where a comment, a response, a correction notice, an Expression of Concern, or a retraction notice is published, it is linked in both directions with the article concerned, so that a reader arriving at either document is made aware of the other. The original article is never removed from the journal’s website, and no post-publication discussion alters the published version of record.

Timeliness
The editorial office acknowledges correspondence within five (5) working days and communicates its assessment of a comment within twenty-eight (28) days. Where a comment and response are accepted for publication, they ordinarily appear in the next scheduled issue.