Peer Review Process

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen operates a double-blind peer review process for every manuscript it publishes. This page sets out the review policy. The sequence of editorial stages and the time allowed for each is described separately on the Publication Process page.

Initial Editorial Assessment
Every submission is first assessed by the editorial office against the journal’s focus and scope, the structural and formatting requirements of the Author Guidelines, the completeness of the compulsory supplementary files, and the maximum similarity index of 20 per cent excluding the reference list.

Manuscripts that fall outside the scope of the journal, or that fail these requirements, are returned to the authors without external review. This decision is taken by the Editor-in-Chief or a delegated section editor and is communicated with reasons. A manuscript returned for formatting or completeness may be resubmitted once the deficiencies have been remedied; a manuscript returned as out of scope may not.

Double-Blind Review
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are sent to a minimum of two independent reviewers holding demonstrated expertise in the subject of the manuscript. Reviewers are drawn from the journal’s reviewer board and from the wider scholarly community, including reviewers affiliated to institutions outside Indonesia.

The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the process. For this reason authors must submit a blinded manuscript in which names, affiliations, acknowledgements, funding details, ethics approval numbers naming the institution, and self-identifying citations have been removed, alongside a full unblinded version uploaded as a supplementary file. Manuscripts in which identifying information remains in the body text or in the file properties are returned for correction before review.

Reviewer Selection and Conflict of Interest
Reviewers are selected on the basis of subject expertise and publication record in the field addressed by the manuscript.

The editorial office does not assign a manuscript to a reviewer affiliated to the same institution as any of the authors, nor to a reviewer who has co-authored with any of the authors within the preceding three years, nor to a reviewer in a current or former supervisory, mentoring, or examining relationship with any of the authors. Reviewers who identify any other personal, professional, financial, or intellectual conflict must decline the invitation and notify the editorial office, as set out on the Conflict of Interest page.

Reviewers who recognise the authorship of a manuscript from its content, and who hold any such interest, must withdraw from the assignment immediately.

Assessment Criteria
Reviewers assess each manuscript against the following criteria:

  1. Originality of the work and the significance of its contribution to knowledge in Christian Religious Education
  2. Clarity of the research problem, the aim, and the stated objectives
  3. Adequacy of the literature review and the identification of a genuine knowledge gap
  4. Appropriateness and rigour of the research method, or, for non-empirical manuscripts, of the theoretical framework and interpretive method
  5. Soundness of the analysis and the extent to which the findings support the conclusions drawn
  6. Relevance of the work to the journal’s focus and scope, and the explicitness of its implications for educational practice
  7. Quality, currency, and adequacy of the references, and accuracy of citation
  8. Clarity, coherence, and academic register of the writing
  9. Compliance with the ethical requirements governing research with human participants, where applicable

Reviews must be substantive and constructive, and must address the scholarly content of the manuscript rather than the presumed identity, institution, or denominational position of its authors. A report consisting of a recommendation without supporting comment is returned to the reviewer for completion.

Recommendations and Editorial Decision
Reviewers submit one of four recommendations: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.

The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief, who weighs the reviewer reports against the standards of the journal. The decision is not determined by majority vote: reviewer reports are advisory, and the editor bears responsibility for the outcome. A manuscript recommended for acceptance by both reviewers may still be rejected where the editor judges that it does not meet the journal’s standards of originality or rigour, and the reasons for such a decision are given to the authors.

Where two reviewers disagree substantially, a third reviewer is appointed and the manuscript is decided in the light of all three reports.

Authors receive the anonymised reviewer comments together with the decision letter. A revision decision requires the authors to submit a revised manuscript accompanied by a point-by-point response letter addressing each comment, including an explanation where a comment has not been adopted. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers for re-evaluation. A manuscript may undergo more than one round of revision.

Editorial and Institutional Submissions
Manuscripts authored by members of the editorial board, or by staff of the publishing institution, are subject to the same review process as every other submission and are handled in full by an editor with no connection to the authors. The authoring editor is removed from the editorial system for that submission and has no access to reviewer identities, reviewer reports, or the decision record. The proportion of articles authored by members of the editorial board and by staff of the publishing institution is kept under review by the editorial board to safeguard the independence and national reach of the journal.

Confidentiality
A manuscript under review is a confidential document. Reviewers and editors must not disclose its content, discuss it with third parties, retain copies beyond the period of the assignment, or make use of unpublished data, ideas, or arguments disclosed in it for their own research. A reviewer who wishes to consult a colleague about a manuscript must obtain the prior permission of the editorial office.

Appeals
Authors who believe a decision rests on a factual error, on a misunderstanding of the manuscript, or on a review that fell short of the standards set out above may appeal in writing to the editorial office within fourteen days of the decision, stating the specific grounds.

Appeals are considered by the Editor-in-Chief and, where appropriate, referred to an additional reviewer. A successful appeal returns the manuscript to the review process; it does not guarantee acceptance. The decision reached on an appeal is final. Dissatisfaction with a decision, unaccompanied by specific grounds, is not a basis for appeal.