Conflict of Interest

Manthano: Jurnal Pendidikan Kristen requires full disclosure of any interest that could reasonably be perceived to influence the conduct, interpretation, or reporting of scholarly work. Disclosure does not disqualify a manuscript, a reviewer, or an editor. Non-disclosure is a breach of publication ethics.

Definition
A conflict of interest exists where professional judgement concerning the validity of research may be influenced by a secondary interest. Such interests may be financial or non-financial, and both carry the same obligation of disclosure.

Financial interests include employment, consultancy, paid advisory roles, research grants, honoraria, paid expert testimony, travel or accommodation funded by an interested party, patents, royalties, and ownership of shares in an organisation with a stake in the subject of the manuscript.

Non-financial interests include personal relationships, academic rivalry, intellectual commitments publicly defended by the author, membership of an advocacy group, office held in a church or denominational body, and institutional, congregational, or denominational affiliation bearing directly on the subject of the manuscript.

Any interest held within the three years preceding submission must be disclosed.

Authors
All authors must declare any competing interests under the Competing Interests sub-heading in the Acknowledgements, together with the funding statement required by the Author Guidelines. Where no such interest exists, the manuscript must state explicitly that the authors declare no competing interests.

Authors writing about an institution, school, congregation, denominational body, programme, or curriculum with which they are affiliated must disclose that affiliation and state their role within it. Research conducted within one’s own institution or faith community is common in Christian education scholarship and is welcome in this journal. The standard the journal applies is transparency rather than avoidance: readers and reviewers must be able to weigh the findings in full knowledge of the author’s position.

Authors evaluating a programme, curriculum, instrument, or model that they themselves designed, own, or stand to benefit from must state this clearly in both the Acknowledgements and the Research Method section.

Reviewers
Reviewers must decline any assignment where they hold a conflict of interest with the authors, the subject matter, or the funder of the research. Grounds for declining include shared institutional affiliation with any author, co-authorship with any author within the preceding three years, a current or former supervisory, mentoring, or examination relationship, a close personal or family relationship, direct involvement in the programme or institution under study, and any direct financial interest in the outcome of the work.

Because the journal operates a double-blind process, reviewers may recognise the authorship of a manuscript from its content. A reviewer who does so and who holds any of the interests above must notify the editorial office immediately and withdraw from the assignment. A reviewer who becomes aware of a conflict at any later stage must do the same.

Editors
Editors must declare any conflict of interest arising from a submission and take no part in the handling of a manuscript in which they hold such an interest. The editor concerned is removed from the editorial system for that submission and has no access to reviewer identities, reviewer reports, or the decision record.

Where the Editor-in-Chief holds a conflict, the manuscript is delegated in full to another member of the editorial board. Manuscripts authored by editors of the journal, or by staff of the publishing institution, are handled entirely by an editor with no connection to the authors, as stated in the Peer Review Process.

Editorial decisions are made on scholarly grounds alone. No consideration is given to the institutional affiliation, denominational background, seniority, or professional relationship of the authors, and no person outside the editorial board holds authority over the outcome of review.

Undisclosed Conflicts
An undisclosed conflict of interest discovered before publication will suspend the review process pending written explanation by the authors. Depending on the explanation, the manuscript may proceed with an amended declaration or be rejected.

Where an undisclosed conflict is discovered after publication, the journal will publish a correction notice amending the declaration or, where the undisclosed interest is material to the findings or their interpretation, retract the article in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy and the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics.