Research Misconduct
Real Coster examines allegations concerning its own manuscripts and published articles, following the flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics. It does not investigate individuals; that belongs to their institutions. Where a finding bears on someone’s professional standing, the matter is referred to the institution concerned.
What constitutes misconduct
Fabrication. Inventing activities, participants, sites, data, or outcomes that did not exist. In this field it includes reporting a programme that was not carried out, or carried out only in part.
Falsification. Misrepresenting what occurred: inflating the number of participants, the duration, the reach, or the scale; presenting attendance as participation; presenting a single visit as a sustained programme; altering photographs, records, or instruments.
Unsupported claims of impact. Asserting that a community changed without evidence that it did, or attributing to the engagement a change the evidence does not connect to it. This is the most common failure in community service writing and the one this journal treats most seriously, because the whole value of such an article rests on the claim.
Breach of consent. Publishing the name, photograph, words, or identifying circumstances of a person or community without the consent required by the Publication Ethics page, or using consent given for one purpose to publish for another.
Harm through publication. Publishing material that exposes a participant to stigma, legal jeopardy, or reprisal, where the authors knew or should have known.
Plagiarism. Presenting another’s words, ideas, data, or structure as one’s own. Screening is described on the Plagiarism page.
Duplicate reporting. Publishing the same engagement twice, including under a different title, a different author combination, or a different framing of the same activity. Where an engagement has been reported before, in any form, this is disclosed at submission.
Fabricated or unverified sources. Citing works that do not exist, or citing a source for something it does not say.
Citation manipulation. Citing to raise a count rather than to support an argument.
Misrepresentation of authorship. Departures from the Authorship Criteria page.
Undisclosed conflict of interest. Failure to declare an interest the Conflict of Interest page requires.
Improper use of artificial intelligence. Use contrary to the AI Policy page, including transmitting community data to such a tool.
Why consent breaches are treated as seriously as data fraud
Fabricated data misleads readers. A breach of consent harms a particular person who had no say in the matter and no means of objecting.
The communities this journal writes about are frequently poor, remote, displaced, or dependent on the institution writing about them. They do not read the journal, do not know they appear in it, and have no standing to complain. The journal’s protection is the only protection they have, which is why the editorial board treats a breach here as gravely as it treats the invention of results.
Raising an allegation
Allegations may be raised by reviewers, editors, readers, or anyone else, including a participant or a community described in an article. They go to the editorial office by electronic mail, identifying the manuscript or article, stating what is alleged, and enclosing whatever evidence the person has.
Anonymous allegations are considered, but are necessarily assessed on the evidence accompanying them, since the editors cannot seek clarification.
The identity of a person raising an allegation in good faith is confidential and is not disclosed to the party complained of, except where law requires it.
Allegations from communities. A complaint from a participant or community about how they have been described is examined under this procedure whether or not consent was previously given. Where the complainant has no electronic mail, the editorial office accepts the complaint through any means and records it.
Procedure
Preliminary assessment. The editors determine whether the allegation falls within this policy and whether the evidence warrants examination. One without substance is closed and the person informed.
Enquiry to the authors. The corresponding author is told the substance of the allegation and invited to respond in writing within fourteen days, with supporting material: field notes, attendance records, consent documentation, raw data, original sources. The authors are heard fully before any conclusion is reached.
Evaluation. The board evaluates the response, consulting an independent specialist in confidence where the matter needs expertise the board lacks. A manuscript under examination is held.
Decision. The board concludes that the allegation is not substantiated; that a minor error occurred requiring correction but not indicating misconduct; or that misconduct occurred.
Notification. The authors, the person who raised the matter, and where appropriate the authors’ institutions are told the outcome in writing.
The board aims to conclude within ninety days. Where a matter is complex or waits on an institutional enquiry elsewhere, the parties are told of the delay and why.
Immediate measures. Where a published article appears to put a named person at risk, the editors may remove the identifying detail at once, while the examination proceeds, and record that they have done so.
Outcomes
In proportion to the seriousness:
- A letter of explanation, where the matter arises from inexperience rather than intent
- Rejection of the manuscript under consideration
- A published correction, where the integrity of the article can be restored
- Retraction, under the Correction and Retraction page
- Referral to the authors’ institutions or funders
- Notification of other journals where the same work has been offered or published
- Refusal of further submissions from the authors responsible, ordinarily for two to five years, in cases of deliberate and serious misconduct
A refusal applies only to those found responsible, not to co-authors with no part in it. The board gives particular consideration to students and junior colleagues who may have acted under direction, and directs its findings accordingly.
Safeguards
Someone raising an allegation in good faith is protected from retaliation; any attempt to penalise them through this journal’s editorial process is itself misconduct.
Authors are presumed to have acted properly until the matter concludes. No public statement is made and no measure affecting the published record is taken before the authors have been heard.
Where a board member is the subject of an allegation, they take no part at any stage.
Records are kept confidentially for ten years, whether or not the allegation was substantiated.
Appeal
An author disputing a finding may appeal in writing to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty days, stating the grounds and submitting any new evidence. The appeal is considered by board members with no part in the original decision. The outcome is final within the journal.
