Manuscript Types

Every manuscript must correspond to one of the types below. Authors state the intended type in the Comments for the Editor field at submission. The editors may reassign a manuscript to a different type, or decline it, where the submitted type does not match the work.

1. Community Empowerment Report

The core type of this journal. An account of a programme the authors designed and carried out with a community, from the identification of need through to what remains afterwards.

  • 4,000 to 7,000 words, excluding references
  • Minimum 25 references
  • Introduction, Method, Results and Discussion, Conclusion

The Method section states how the need was identified, who was involved in deciding what to do, what was carried out, over what period, and how change was measured. The Results section reports outcomes against the baseline, including what fell short. The Conclusion states what continues after the implementers withdraw.

A single visit, a one-off seminar, or the delivery of goods does not constitute a programme under this type.

2. Participatory Action Research

Work in which the community takes part in defining the problem, planning the response, acting, and reflecting, across at least one full cycle.

  • 5,000 to 8,000 words
  • Minimum 30 references
  • Introduction, Method, Cycles of Action and Reflection, Discussion, Conclusion

The manuscript names the participants and their role at each stage, distinguishes what the community decided from what the researchers decided, and reports how the plan changed in response to reflection. An account in which participation amounts to attendance belongs under Type 1.

3. Model and Module Development

The design, testing, and revision of a model, module, curriculum, training package, or instrument intended for use by others.

  • 5,000 to 8,000 words
  • Minimum 30 references
  • Introduction, Development Method, The Model or Module, Testing and Revision, Conclusion

The manuscript states the development procedure followed, how the product was validated and by whom, the results of trialling it with actual users, and what was revised as a result. The product itself must be described in sufficient detail for another institution to use it, or supplied as a supplementary file.

An untested design is not publishable under this type.

4. Needs Assessment and Baseline Study

Systematic study of a community’s situation, conducted to inform engagement rather than to report it.

  • 4,000 to 6,000 words
  • Minimum 25 references
  • Introduction, Method, Findings, Implications for Engagement, Conclusion

The manuscript states how the community was selected, how data were gathered, and who was consulted. The implications section sets out what the findings mean for anyone planning to work there. A study conducted purely to produce knowledge, with no engagement in view, belongs in a social science journal.

5. Impact and Outcome Evaluation

Assessment of what a programme achieved, conducted after implementation. The programme may be the authors’ own or another body’s.

  • 5,000 to 8,000 words
  • Minimum 30 references
  • Introduction, Evaluation Method, Findings, Discussion, Conclusion

The manuscript states the evaluation design, the criteria applied, the evidence drawn upon, and the time elapsed since the programme ended. Where the authors evaluate their own work, this is stated plainly in the Method and the measures taken to limit bias are described.

Evaluation that reports only success is not credible and will be returned.

6. Reflective Practice Paper

Analytical reflection on engagement already carried out, examining what the experience teaches about practice. This type exists chiefly for accounts of work that did not go as intended.

  • 3,500 to 6,000 words
  • Minimum 20 references
  • Introduction, The Engagement, Analysis, Lessons for Practice, Conclusion

The manuscript must do more than narrate. It identifies what assumption, method, or relationship failed, examines why, and sets out what practitioners should do differently. The editors regard honest accounts of difficulty as among the most useful work this journal can publish.

7. Conceptual and Ethical Study

Theoretical examination of faith based community engagement: its warrants, its ethics, its models, or its critique.

  • 5,000 to 7,000 words
  • Minimum 35 references
  • Introduction, Method, Discussion under thematic subheadings, Conclusion

The Method section states the approach taken, the sources analysed, and the limits of the study. The argument must be anchored in documented practice, whether the authors’ own or published cases, and must reach a conclusion practitioners can act on.

8. Book Review

By invitation of the editorial board, maximum one per issue.

  • 1,500 to 2,500 words
  • Bibliographic details, summary of the argument, critical assessment, relevance to community service practice
  • Reviewed editorially, not counted as a research article

Requirements common to all types

Every manuscript states the location and period of the engagement, the number and character of the participants, the funding that supported it, and the institutional permissions obtained.

Where individuals are identifiable, whether by name, photograph, or circumstance, the manuscript states that their consent was obtained. Communities, congregations, schools, and villages are named only with the agreement of their leadership. Where a participant is a child, consent from a parent or guardian is required.

Photographs are published only where they serve the argument. Images of individuals receiving aid, of distress, or of children’s faces are not accepted as illustration.

Title, abstract of 150 to 200 words, and three to five keywords are supplied in both Bahasa Indonesia and English.