Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest exists where someone involved in evaluating or publishing a manuscript holds an interest capable of influencing their judgement, or capable of being reasonably seen to.
Holding an interest is not improper, and declaring one is not an admission of fault. What damages a journal is concealment. Real Coster therefore requires disclosure from authors, reviewers, and editors, and manages what is disclosed rather than merely recording it.
The structural conflict in this field
Community service scholarship carries a conflict that is not incidental but built into it: authors ordinarily evaluate their own work.
The people who designed a programme, raised its funding, and carried it out are the same people who report whether it succeeded. Their standing, their institution’s reputation, and often their next grant rest on the answer. No disclosure removes this. It can only be managed.
Real Coster manages it by requiring that every manuscript state plainly that the authors are reporting their own engagement, report what did not work alongside what did, name the evidence behind every claim of change, and distinguish the community’s assessment of the outcome from the implementers’ own.
A manuscript that reads as an unbroken account of success is not treated as exemplary. It is treated as incomplete.
Interests that must be declared
Financial
- Funding, grants, or sponsorship for the engagement reported, named with the amount’s source
- Employment, consultancy, or paid advisory work with a body having an interest in the findings
- A commercial stake in a product, model, module, curriculum, or training package evaluated or recommended
- Royalties, honoraria, or payment in kind connected with the subject of the manuscript
- Pending applications whose outcome a favourable report would assist
Professional and institutional
- Membership of this journal’s editorial board
- Employment at or affiliation with the publishing institution
- Recent collaboration, co-authorship, or joint work with another party to the manuscript
- Service as a supervisor, examiner, or mentor to an author
- Leadership or governance of the implementing body, the funding body, or the institution evaluated
- Competition with an author for the same funding, position, or recognition
Ecclesial and community
- Office or ministry in the congregation, denomination, synod, or foundation whose work the manuscript reports
- A pastoral, teaching, or employment relationship with participants in the engagement
- A position of authority within the community served
- Membership of a body that would be criticised or vindicated by the findings
The third group is particular to this journal. In community service the author is frequently the pastor, the teacher, or the employer of the people whose gratitude the manuscript reports. That relationship shapes what participants feel able to say, and it must be declared so that readers can weigh the evidence accordingly.
Authors
The corresponding author declares, for all authors, any interest in the categories above, in the declarations before the references. Where there is nothing to declare, this is stated rather than left blank.
Where the manuscript evaluates a programme, institution, or product in which any author holds a stake or an office, the relationship is described in the body of the manuscript as well, not only in the declarations.
Funding is named in every case, including where the authors funded the work themselves or where a congregation or foundation met the costs.
A declared interest never prejudices evaluation. No manuscript is declined on the ground of a declared interest alone.
Reviewers
A reviewer holding an interest declines the invitation and tells the editorial office why. One who recognises an interest after starting withdraws and returns the manuscript without comment.
In this field, reviewers are often drawn from the same networks of churches, foundations, and seminaries as the authors. A reviewer uncertain whether a connection requires withdrawal raises it with the editor rather than deciding privately. The judgement belongs to the editor.
Editors
An editor holding an interest withdraws, and the manuscript is reassigned to an editor who conducts the process independently and whose decision is final.
Manuscripts by editors. Where a board member submits, they have no access to the editorial record, no part in selecting reviewers, and no knowledge of who they are. Where the Editor-in-Chief is an author, another board member is designated to handle it.
Manuscripts from the publishing institution. Work by staff, students, or partner congregations of Institut Agama Kristen REAL Batam is handled as any other submission and reviewed by reviewers from outside the institution. The journal’s position on such manuscripts is set out on the Ownership and Management page.
Management
Disclosure is not the end of the matter. Depending on the interest, the editors may publish the declaration with the article, which is the ordinary course; appoint additional reviewers from outside the field, institution, or network concerned; require the relationship to be stated in the body of the article; reassign the handling editor; or decline the manuscript where no measure can preserve the integrity of the evaluation.
Undisclosed interests
An interest that emerges during review suspends consideration while the corresponding author is invited to explain. One that emerges after publication is examined under the Research Misconduct page and may lead to a correction or, in a serious case, a retraction.
Enquiries
Anyone who believes an undisclosed interest has affected a manuscript or a published article may write to the editorial office. Enquiries are confidential and are examined by an editor with no involvement in the work.
