Correction and Retraction
A published article is part of the permanent record. Where an error or a breach is found, Real Coster corrects the record openly rather than amending or removing the article quietly. This page follows the retraction guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics and applies to articles already published; manuscripts not yet published are governed by the Withdrawal of Manuscript page.
Principles
The published version is never altered. Corrections and retractions are separate documents linked to it in both directions. Nothing is deleted from the archive, and digital object identifiers continue to resolve. Every notice is published in a current issue, carries its own identifier, is registered with Crossref, and is free to read. A notice states what changed and why, in terms that inform rather than accuse.
Correction
Published where an error affects part of an article but the findings stand: a figure or table reproduced wrongly, a wrong reference or scriptural citation, an error in a name or affiliation, an omitted funding or conflict of interest statement, a miscalculation that does not alter the conclusions, or a misstatement of the number of participants, the period, or the location of the engagement.
The notice appears as Correction to: [title], giving the original citation, the error, and the corrected text.
Retraction
Published where the findings are unreliable or the article should not have appeared. The grounds are:
- Fabricated or falsified activities, participants, data, or outcomes
- Claims of impact that the evidence does not support, where the claim is central to the article
- Substantial plagiarism
- The same engagement already published elsewhere without disclosure
- The engagement conducted without the consent or institutional permission it required
- Publication in breach of the consent given by a community or its members
- Authorship materially misrepresented
- A concealed conflict of interest found to have affected the findings
- Fabricated sources, to an extent that the argument cannot stand
The notice appears as Retraction: [title], giving the original citation, the ground, who requested it, and the date. The article stays on the website with a statement at the head of its page identifying it as retracted and linking to the notice.
Retraction concerns the reliability of the work, not the character of its authors. An article may be retracted at the authors’ own request where they find a serious error in their own work, and the notice says so. The editorial board regards such a request as the conduct of responsible scholars.
Partial retraction
Where a defined part is unreliable while the rest stands, a partial retraction identifies precisely which findings are withdrawn.
Expression of concern
Published where the board has substantial grounds to doubt an article but cannot yet conclude: an institutional enquiry is under way, or the authors do not respond. It states the nature of the concern and that the matter remains open, and is replaced by a correction, a retraction, or a notice of resolution once concluded.
Removal
Reserved for the rare case where the article is unlawful, defames an identifiable person, or breaches the privacy of a participant so seriously that leaving it available would cause harm.
In this journal that includes an article identifying a person or community in a way that exposes them to stigma, legal jeopardy, or reprisal, where the harm cannot be remedied by correcting the text.
The metadata, title, and author names remain, with a statement of the reason. Removal requires the approval of the Editor-in-Chief and of the publishing institution.
The board does not remove an article on any other ground, including a change of institutional affiliation, a disagreement arising after publication, a funder’s displeasure with a finding, or an author’s later discomfort with what the article reports.
Redaction of identifying detail
Distinct from removal, and particular to this journal. Where a name, a photograph, or a circumstance in a published article puts a person at risk, the editors may redact that detail while leaving the article in place.
A redaction is recorded in a dated note on the article page stating that identifying material has been removed and why, without repeating the material. The DOI does not change. Where the redaction alters anything a reader relied upon, a correction notice is issued as well.
This may be done at once, before an examination concludes, where there is reason to believe someone is at risk.
How a matter is raised and decided
Authors who find an error in their own article tell the editorial office without delay. Readers with grounds to doubt an article may write to the office. A participant or community may raise a concern about how they have been represented, by any means, whether or not consent was given before.
Where integrity is in question the matter goes to the Research Misconduct procedure and the authors are heard before any measure is taken. Where it is straightforward error, the editors verify it with the authors and issue a correction.
The decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief on the board’s advice. The editors seek the authors’ agreement, but a notice may be published without it where the record requires correcting. Where the authors disagree with a retraction, their dissent is recorded in the notice.
Notification
The editorial office informs the authors, the person who raised the matter, the indexing services carrying the journal, and, where the article has been widely cited, others who need to know.
Appeal
An author disputing a correction or retraction may appeal in writing to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty days, under the procedure on the Research Misconduct page. A notice stays in place while an appeal is considered, and is amended or withdrawn if the appeal succeeds.
