Peer Review Process

Real Coster operates double blind peer review. Author identities are withheld from reviewers and reviewer identities from authors. Every manuscript under a type designated for review on the Manuscript Types page passes through the stages below.

1. Editorial screening

The editorial office checks the manuscript for scope, compliance with the template, completeness of the declarations, and similarity.

Screening at this journal also tests one thing that cannot wait for review: whether the manuscript establishes the elements set out on the Focus and Scope page — the situation before the engagement, the community’s involvement, what was done and for how long, what changed and on what evidence, what fell short, what continues, and what transfers. A manuscript that narrates an activity without these is returned without review.

The consent requirements on the Manuscript Types page are checked at this stage, not later. A manuscript naming a community, an institution, or an identifiable individual without stating that consent was obtained is returned until it does.

Authors are told the outcome within two weeks.

2. Assignment of reviewers

Manuscripts that pass screening go to at least two reviewers, chosen for expertise in the field of the engagement rather than in theology alone. A health programme is reviewed by someone who understands health programmes; a livelihood intervention by someone who understands livelihoods. Where the journal’s reviewer pool lacks the competence a manuscript requires, the editors appoint from outside it.

Reviewers from the same institution as any author are not appointed, nor is anyone holding an interest within the meaning of the Conflict of Interest page.

The editorial office removes identifying details from the file before it is sent and checks the document properties. Authors prepare an anonymised file as described in the Author Guidelines.

3. Review

Reviewers assess the manuscript against the criteria appropriate to its type. Those applied in common are:

Evidence. Is the claimed change supported, or asserted? Are the sources of evidence named, and adequate to the claim? A programme reported as successful without evidence of what changed is not publishable.

Community position. Does the account show the community as participant, or as recipient? Whose assessment of the outcome is reported — the implementers’ or the community’s?

Method. Is the engagement described in enough detail that another institution could attempt it? Are the period, scale, and participants stated?

Candour. Does the manuscript report what did not work? Reports composed entirely of success are treated as incomplete rather than exemplary.

Sustainability. Is there an account of what continues after the implementers withdraw, or does the engagement end at the point of writing?

Ethics. Is consent reported? Are participants protected? Do the photographs, if any, respect the dignity of the people in them?

Scholarship. Does the manuscript engage the literature of its field, and is its contribution stated?

Reviewers file a report through the submission system and recommend accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject. Reports are expected within four weeks; where a reviewer cannot meet this, the editorial office appoints a replacement.

A review is an expert judgement for which the reviewer is personally accountable. It may not be delegated to a generative artificial intelligence tool, and the manuscript may not be uploaded to one. See the AI Policy page.

4. Editorial decision

The handling editor weighs the reports and decides. Where two reports diverge materially, a third reviewer is appointed. Decisions are not settled by counting recommendations; a well reasoned minority report may decide the matter.

Authors receive the decision together with the reviewers’ comments, with identities withheld.

5. Revision

Revised manuscripts are accompanied by a point by point response stating what changed and where, or why a recommendation was not followed. The editors do not require every recommendation to be accepted, but every one must be answered.

Substantial revisions return to the original reviewers; minor ones are assessed by the handling editor. A manuscript may go through more than one round.

6. Acceptance and publication

On acceptance the manuscript proceeds to copyediting, layout, and proofreading. Authors check proofs for the accuracy of names, affiliations, figures, and references. The article is then assigned a DOI, registered with Crossref, and published in the next issue.

Appeal

An author who considers a decision to rest on a material misunderstanding may appeal in writing to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty days, stating the grounds. The appeal is considered by an editor who had no part in the original decision and may lead to a further review. The outcome is final. Disagreement with a reviewer’s judgement is not in itself a ground for appeal.

Reviewers

Reviewers serve without payment. Those who have served the journal are listed on the Peer Review page. The journal does not disclose which reviewer assessed which manuscript, including after publication.