Publication Ethic

Real Coster follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics. The responsibilities below apply to everyone involved in the journal. Matters governed in detail elsewhere are named rather than restated.

Responsibilities toward the community served

This journal publishes accounts of work done with people, many of them in positions of need or dependence. Their interests come before the interests of authors, of the journal, and of the institutions involved.

Consent to publish is separate from consent to serve. A community that accepted help did not thereby agree to appear in a journal. Authors obtain consent for publication specifically, and state in the manuscript that they did so.

Who may give consent. Leadership consent is required to name a village, congregation, school, or institution. It does not substitute for the consent of individuals who are identifiable within it. Where a participant is a child, consent comes from a parent or guardian.

Dignity in representation. Participants are described as people, not as cases or beneficiaries. Photographs of individuals receiving aid, of visible distress, or of children’s faces are not published. Circumstances are not recounted in detail sufficient to identify a person who has not consented to be identified.

No harm from publication. Where publishing a detail could expose a participant to stigma, legal risk, or reprisal, it is withheld, and the authors say that a detail has been withheld and why.

Service is not conditional. Participation in a programme must never have depended on the recipient’s religious response, nor on willingness to be photographed, interviewed, or written about.

For authors

Accuracy. Report what occurred, including what fell short. Overstating reach, duration, or effect is a misrepresentation, and is treated under the Research Misconduct page.

Evidence. Claims of change rest on evidence the manuscript names. The community’s own assessment is reported where it exists, and distinguished from the implementers’ assessment.

Originality. The work is original, unpublished, and not before another journal. A programme reported once is not reported again under a new title.

Acknowledgement. Partner institutions, funders, volunteers, and community members who made the work possible are acknowledged with their permission.

Authorship follows the Authorship Criteria page. Conflicts of interest are declared as the Conflict of Interest page requires. Artificial intelligence is used and disclosed as the AI Policy page requires. Errors found after publication are reported to the editors at once, under the Correction and Retraction page.

For editors

Decisions rest on the quality of the engagement and the evidence, as set out on the Peer Review Process page.

Fairness. Manuscripts are assessed on content, whatever the author’s background, institution, denomination, or tradition.

Confidentiality. A manuscript under consideration is confidential. Its content is not used, cited, or passed on.

Recusal. An editor holding an interest withdraws and the manuscript is reassigned, as the Conflict of Interest page sets out.

Protection of participants. Editors may require a name, a photograph, or a detail to be removed where publication could cause harm, even when the authors hold consent.

Allegations are examined under the Research Misconduct page, with the authors given opportunity to respond.

For reviewers

Objectivity. Criticism addresses the work, never the person. Honest reports of difficulty are assessed on their analytical value, not penalised for reporting failure.

Confidentiality. A manuscript under review is not shared, cited, or used, and is not uploaded to a generative artificial intelligence tool.

Recusal. A reviewer holding an interest declines, before or during the review.

Promptness. A reviewer unable to finish within the agreed period tells the editorial office so a replacement can be found.

Vigilance. Anything suggesting undeclared duplication, absent consent, or an unsupported claim of impact is raised with the editors rather than left in the report to the authors.

For the publisher

The publisher safeguards editorial independence, upholds the ethical standards of the journal, discloses its ownership and funding on the Ownership and Management page, protects authors’ rights under the Copyright and License page, and preserves the published record as the Archive Policy page describes.

Raising a concern

Anyone may write to the editorial office about a manuscript or a published article, including members of a community described in one. Concerns are examined under the Research Misconduct page, in confidence, by an editor with no involvement in the work.

A concern raised by a participant or a community about how they have been represented is taken seriously whether or not consent was previously given, and may lead to correction or retraction.