Authorship Criteria

Real Coster follows the criteria of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors, adapted to community service scholarship.

Criteria

An author must satisfy all four conditions:

  • Substantial contribution to the design of the engagement, to its implementation, or to the analysis and interpretation of what it produced
  • Drafting the manuscript or revising it critically for important intellectual content
  • Approval of the submitted version and of any revision
  • Accountability for the whole work, including the conduct of the engagement it reports

Someone who meets only the first is not an author. Someone who meets all four may not be left out.

Participation in the engagement does not by itself confer authorship

This is the distinction that matters most in community service, and the one most often blurred.

Many people make a programme possible. They drive, cook, translate, open doors, carry equipment, lend a hall, give a week of their time. Their contribution is real and should be acknowledged, but taking part in an activity is not the same as contributing to a scholarly account of it. Authorship belongs to those who shaped the work intellectually and who can answer for what the manuscript claims.

The following, standing alone, do not establish authorship:

  • Attending or assisting at the activity
  • Holding office in the implementing institution, the sponsoring church, or the host community
  • Heading the department, faculty, or foundation under which the work was carried out
  • Providing funding, facilities, transport, or permission
  • Collecting data under instruction
  • Being a member of a team whose other members did the work

Such contributions belong in the Acknowledgements, with the permission of the person named.

Large author groups

Manuscripts in this field often carry many authors. Where more than five are listed, the editorial office may ask the corresponding author to state what each contributed. Where the statement shows that some did not meet the criteria, the editors ask for the list to be corrected before review proceeds.

A long list is not evidence of a large programme. It is more often evidence that participation has been mistaken for authorship.

Students and supervisors

Work arising from student community service is welcome. Where a manuscript rests on a student’s engagement and analysis, the student is ordinarily the first author. A supervisor is a co-author only where their own contribution meets the four criteria; supervision alone does not.

Authorship is agreed before the manuscript is written, not after it is accepted.

Community members as authors

Where a member of the community served has contributed to the design, the analysis, or the writing in a way that meets the criteria, they are named as an author, whatever their academic standing. The journal places no institutional requirement on authorship.

Where community members contributed to the work but not to the scholarship, they are acknowledged, by name where they consent to be named and collectively where they do not.

Names, affiliations, and order

Order is decided by the authors and should reflect the weight of contribution. The journal does not impose an order and does not arbitrate between authors.

Names are published as supplied. Authors give the form they use consistently across their publications, so their work can be traced. A mononym is entered as such and not duplicated.

Affiliation is the institution at which the author was based when the work was carried out, given in the institution’s own official form with city and country. Authors who have since moved may add a present affiliation in a note. An ORCID identifier is encouraged.

Where an author’s affiliation is a church, foundation, or other non-academic body, it is given in full and in its own right. Practitioner authorship is normal in this journal and requires no academic affiliation.

The corresponding author

One author communicates with the editorial office. The corresponding author confirms that all named authors have approved the submission, answers editorial and reviewer correspondence on behalf of all, is responsible for the accuracy of names and affiliations, and passes decisions on to the others. The role carries no additional credit.

The corresponding author also holds the consents obtained from the community and its members, and produces them if the editors ask.

Artificial intelligence

A generative tool cannot be an author, having no capacity to approve a manuscript or answer for it. Use of such tools is disclosed as the AI Policy page requires, and the authors remain fully responsible for the content.

Contribution statement

Every manuscript carries a statement of author contributions before the list of references, saying what each author did. For a single author, this is stated.

Changes after submission

Adding, removing, or reordering authors requires a written request from the corresponding author stating the reason and confirming that every author, including any to be removed, agrees in writing. After publication, changes are made only through the procedure on the Correction and Retraction page.

Disputes

Where an authorship dispute reaches the editors, consideration is suspended until it is resolved. The journal does not arbitrate; that belongs to the parties’ institutions. The editors follow COPE guidance in deciding whether to proceed with, decline, or withdraw the manuscript.