Research Misconduct

REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education is committed to the integrity of the scholarly record. Where an allegation of misconduct is raised in connection with a manuscript submitted to or published by this journal, the editorial board examines it according to the procedure set out below, following the flowcharts issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

The journal examines allegations relating to its own manuscripts and published articles. It does not investigate the conduct of individuals, which is the responsibility of their institutions. Where an allegation is substantiated in a manner that bears on a person’s professional standing, the editorial board refers the matter to the institution concerned.

What constitutes misconduct

Fabrication. Inventing data, observations, interview responses, participants, research sites, or results that were never obtained.

Falsification. Manipulating research materials, data, images, or results so that the research is not accurately represented, including the selective omission of findings that do not support a conclusion.

Plagiarism. Presenting the words, ideas, data, or structure of another person as one’s own, without appropriate acknowledgement. The journal’s screening procedure is described on the Plagiarism page.

Fabricated or unverified sources. Citing works that do not exist, attributing to a source a statement it does not contain, or reproducing a quotation without consulting the work in which it appears. In a field that reasons from texts, this includes misquotation of Scripture, misattribution of a translation, and claims about the original languages that the cited reference works do not support.

Redundant and duplicate publication. Submitting a manuscript substantially overlapping with work already published or under consideration elsewhere, without disclosure to the editors. This includes dividing a single study into several manuscripts in order to multiply publications, where the parts have no independent scholarly value.

Citation manipulation. Including citations whose purpose is to increase the citation count of a particular author, journal, or institution rather than to support the argument of the manuscript.

Misrepresentation of authorship. Departures from the journal’s Authorship Criteria, including gift, ghost, and purchased authorship.

Undisclosed conflict of interest. Failure to declare an interest required by the journal’s Conflict of Interest policy.

Undisclosed use of generative artificial intelligence. Use of such tools in a manner contrary to the journal’s AI Policy.

Ethical breaches in research involving human participants. Conducting research without the consent required of participants or, where participants are minors, of their parents or guardians; proceeding without institutional ethical approval where such approval was required; or breaching the confidentiality or anonymity promised to participants or to the schools, seminaries, and congregations in which the research was conducted.

The last category carries particular weight in this journal. Research in Christian education is commonly conducted among students, including minors, and within congregations where the researcher may hold a position of pastoral or institutional authority over the participants. Consent obtained in such a relationship requires particular care, and participants must be free to decline without consequence. The editorial board regards a breach of consent, confidentiality, or anonymity in these settings as a serious matter, irrespective of the scholarly quality of the resulting manuscript.

Raising an allegation

Allegations may be raised by reviewers, editors, readers, or any other party, and should be addressed to the editorial office by electronic mail. An allegation should identify the manuscript or published article, state what is alleged, and provide whatever supporting evidence is available to the person raising it.

The editorial board considers allegations raised anonymously, but such allegations are necessarily assessed on the strength of the evidence accompanying them, since the editors cannot seek clarification from the person who raised them.

The identity of a person raising an allegation in good faith is treated as confidential and is not disclosed to the party complained of, except where disclosure is required by law.

Procedure

First stage: preliminary assessment. The editors determine whether the allegation falls within the scope of this policy and whether it is supported by evidence sufficient to warrant examination. An allegation found to be without substance is closed at this stage, and the person who raised it is informed.

Second stage: enquiry to the authors. Where the allegation warrants examination, the corresponding author is informed of its substance and invited to respond in writing within fourteen days, together with any supporting material such as raw data, drafts, consent documentation, or original sources. The authors are given a full opportunity to explain before any conclusion is reached.

Third stage: evaluation. The editorial board evaluates the response. Where the matter requires expertise the board does not hold, an independent specialist may be consulted in confidence. Consideration of a manuscript under examination is suspended until the matter is concluded.

Fourth stage: decision. The editorial board reaches one of the following conclusions: that the allegation is not substantiated; that a minor error occurred, requiring correction but not indicating misconduct; or that misconduct occurred.

Fifth stage: notification. The authors, the person who raised the allegation, and, where appropriate, the institutions of the authors are informed of the outcome in writing.

The editorial board aims to conclude the procedure within ninety days of an allegation being raised. Where a matter is complex or depends on an institutional enquiry elsewhere, the parties are informed of the delay and of the reason for it.

Outcomes

The measures available to the editorial board, applied in proportion to the seriousness of the matter, are as follows.

  • A letter of explanation to the authors, where the matter arises from inexperience rather than intent
  • Rejection of the manuscript under consideration
  • Publication of a correction, where the integrity of the article can be restored
  • Retraction of the published article, in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy
  • Referral of the matter to the institutions of the authors or to their funding bodies
  • Notification of other journals, where the same work has been submitted or published elsewhere
  • A prohibition on further submissions by the authors to this journal for a defined period, ordinarily between two and five years, in cases of deliberate and serious misconduct

A prohibition on further submissions applies only to the authors found responsible, and not to co-authors who had no part in the matter. The editorial board gives particular consideration to the position of students and early-career authors who may have acted under the direction of a supervisor, and directs its findings accordingly.

Safeguards

A person who raises an allegation in good faith is protected from retaliation. Any attempt to penalise such a person through the editorial process of this journal is itself treated as misconduct.

An author against whom an allegation is raised is presumed to have acted properly until the matter is concluded. No public statement is made, and no measure is taken affecting the published record, before the authors have been heard and a conclusion reached.

Where a member of the editorial board is the subject of an allegation, that member has no part in any stage of the procedure, which is conducted by other members of the board.

Records of allegations and their outcomes are retained confidentially by the editorial office for ten years, whether or not the allegation was substantiated.

Appeal

An author who disputes a finding of misconduct may appeal in writing to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty days, stating the grounds of the appeal and submitting any new evidence. An appeal is considered by members of the editorial board who had no part in the original decision. The outcome of an appeal is final within the journal.