Screaning Plagiarism

REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education upholds academic integrity and does not tolerate plagiarism in any form. Every submitted manuscript is screened using similarity detection software before it proceeds to peer review.

Screening procedure

Screening is carried out by the editorial office at the initial screening stage, using Turnitin. The manuscript is checked in full, including the body of the text and the list of references.

A manuscript is screened again after substantial revision and once more before publication, to ensure that material introduced during revision has not altered the result.

The similarity report is an instrument, not a verdict. The editors examine the report itself rather than acting on the overall figure alone, and assess where the matched text occurs and what it consists of.

Similarity threshold

  • Up to 20% — the manuscript proceeds to peer review.
  • Between 21% and 30% — the manuscript is returned to the author for revision to reduce the similarity level. It may be resubmitted once revised, and is screened again.
  • Above 30% — the manuscript is declined.

These figures are read in the light of the examination described below. A manuscript whose overall figure falls within the permitted range may still be returned or declined where a single source accounts for a substantial share of the match, or where matched text appears in passages that ought to be the author’s own analysis. Conversely, a manuscript whose figure exceeds the threshold may be allowed to proceed where the match consists wholly of material of the kind listed in the next section.

Matches that are not treated as plagiarism

The following commonly raise the overall figure without indicating any breach of integrity, and are discounted in the editors’ assessment.

  • Quotations from Scripture, correctly attributed with book, chapter, and verse
  • Properly attributed quotations from other sources, enclosed in quotation marks or set as block quotations
  • Standard theological and educational terminology, creedal and liturgical formulae, and confessional statements
  • Names of institutions, instruments, legal provisions, and government regulations
  • Entries in the list of references
  • Standard methodological descriptions where no alternative wording is available

What constitutes plagiarism

  • Reproducing text from another source without quotation marks and attribution
  • Paraphrasing another author’s work so closely that the structure and sequence of the original remain intact, even where the source is cited
  • Using the ideas, data, arguments, or findings of others without adequate acknowledgement
  • Reproducing a translation of a source without identifying the translator, or presenting another’s translation as one’s own
  • Reusing substantial portions of one’s own previously published work without disclosure, which is self-plagiarism
  • Reproducing material generated by an artificial intelligence tool as one’s own composition, contrary to the AI Policy

Self-plagiarism

Authors may draw on their own earlier work, but must cite it as they would cite any other source. A manuscript developed from a thesis, dissertation, or conference paper is acceptable, provided the authors disclose this at submission and the manuscript represents a substantial development rather than a reproduction. Such disclosure is made in the Comments for the Editor field.

Detection after publication

Where plagiarism is discovered in a published article, the matter is examined under the Research Misconduct policy. Where the finding is substantiated, the editorial board issues a correction or retracts the article in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy. The article is not removed from the website.

Responsibility of authors

Authors are fully responsible for the originality of their manuscripts. By submitting to this journal, the authors affirm that the work is their own, that all sources are properly acknowledged, and that it has not been published elsewhere in any form.

Authors are encouraged to screen their manuscript themselves before submission. The journal does not supply similarity reports to authors, but informs them of the overall figure where a manuscript is returned on this ground.