Manuscript Types
REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education accepts manuscripts in the field of Christian Religious Education, examined through philosophical, theological, pedagogical, spiritual, and practical approaches. Every manuscript must correspond to one of the types described below. Authors state the intended type in the Comments for the Editor field at submission.
Unless stated otherwise, all types are subject to double-blind peer review and must follow the Author Guidelines and the official journal template, observe the journal’s Authorship Criteria, Conflict of Interest, and Artificial Intelligence policies, and satisfy the similarity threshold stated on the Plagiarism page.
1. Original Research Article
Reports of original empirical studies in Christian education, including qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-methods research, classroom action research, evaluation studies, and the development of curricula, instruments, or learning media.
- Length: 5,000–7,000 words, excluding references
- Minimum references: 30, at least 80% primary sources
- Structure: Introduction — Research Methods — Results and Discussion — Conclusion
- Studies involving students, teachers, parents, or congregants as participants must report informed consent and, where required, institutional ethical approval. Where participants are minors, the written consent of a parent or guardian is required
2. Conceptual Article
Theoretical and philosophical studies that construct, reconstruct, or critically examine a framework for Christian education. This type covers engagement with educational philosophy and learning theory, the interrogation of pedagogical assumptions, and the development of conceptual models for teaching and formation in faith. Manuscripts of this type are not required to report field data, but they must demonstrate a disciplined method of inquiry and must not consist of unstructured reflection.
- Length: 5,000–7,000 words, excluding references
- Minimum references: 35, at least 80% primary sources
- Structure: Introduction — Method, stating the approach used (for example conceptual-analytical, critical-constructive, or comparative), the sources analysed, and the limits of the study — Discussion, organised under thematic subheadings that develop the argument — Conclusion
- The manuscript must state its thesis explicitly and establish its contribution to Christian education, not to philosophy or theology considered on their own
3. Biblical-Theological Study
Exegetical and theological studies of biblical texts or doctrinal themes, carried out with the aim of drawing out implications for Christian education. This type recognises that a substantial part of scholarship in this field proceeds from the text of Scripture rather than from empirical data, and it provides that work with a structure appropriate to it.
- Length: 5,000–7,000 words, excluding references
- Minimum references: 30, including commentaries, lexical and grammatical reference works, and scholarly monographs on the passage or theme
- Structure: Introduction — Method, stating the exegetical or theological approach used (for example grammatical-historical, socio-rhetorical, narrative, or systematic-theological), the text or corpus examined, and the version or critical edition relied upon — Exegesis or Theological Analysis — Educational Implications — Conclusion
- The section on educational implications is required, not optional. A manuscript that establishes the meaning of a text without carrying it into the practice or theory of Christian education falls outside the scope of this journal
- Claims about the original languages must be substantiated. Transliteration follows the convention stated in the Author Guidelines, and lexical arguments must engage recognised reference works rather than rest on word studies alone
4. Systematic Literature Review
Structured reviews that map, synthesise, and critically evaluate a defined body of scholarship on a specific question in Christian education. Narrative summaries of unrelated sources are not accepted under this type.
- Length: 6,000–8,000 words, excluding references
- Minimum references: 45, predominantly peer-reviewed journal articles
- Structure: Introduction — Review Method, stating the research question, databases consulted, search string, time span, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and selection flow — Findings and Discussion — Conclusion
- Authors are encouraged to follow PRISMA or an equivalent protocol, and to include a selection flow diagram and a summary table of the reviewed studies
5. Practice-Based Report
Documented accounts of educational practice in Christian learning environments, including schools, catechism and confirmation classes, Sunday schools, seminaries, and family-based instruction. This type is intended for educators and must move beyond description toward analysis.
- Length: 4,000–6,000 words, excluding references
- Minimum references: 20
- Structure: Introduction — Context and Implementation — Analysis and Reflection — Conclusion and Recommendations
- The manuscript must situate the practice within existing scholarship and state what is transferable to other settings
A note on scope: this type concerns teaching and formation. Reports of community service programmes conducted by institutions for the benefit of a wider community belong to Real Coster: Jurnal Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat, published by the same institution. Where a manuscript sits on the boundary, the editors will advise the author which journal is the better fit.
6. Book Review
Critical reviews of recent scholarly books within the scope of the journal, normally published within the last five years. Published by invitation of the editorial board, with a maximum of one review per issue.
- Length: 1,500–2,500 words
- Structure: full bibliographic details, summary of the argument, critical assessment, and statement of relevance to Christian education
- Reviewed editorially rather than through double-blind peer review, and not counted as a research article
7. Editorial
Written or commissioned by the editorial board to introduce an issue, frame a thematic edition, or address a development in the field. Not peer reviewed and not counted as a research article.
- Length: 1,000–2,000 words
General Requirements
- The manuscript is original, unpublished, and not under consideration elsewhere.
- Title, abstract of 150–200 words, and 3–5 keywords are supplied in both Bahasa Indonesia and English.
- All named authors meet the journal’s Authorship Criteria, and a statement of author contributions is included.
- Conflict of interest, funding, use of generative artificial intelligence, and, where applicable, ethical approval and informed consent are declared before the list of references.
- Scripture quotations in Indonesian follow the Terjemahan Baru of the Lembaga Alkitab Indonesia unless the author states and justifies another version.
- The editorial board may reassign a manuscript to a different type, or decline it, where the submitted type does not match the content of the work.

