Publication Ethic

REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education is committed to upholding the highest standards of publication ethics. The journal follows the Core Practices and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). The responsibilities set out below apply to all parties involved in the publication process. Where a matter is governed in detail by a separate policy, that policy is identified.

For Authors

Accuracy. Authors must present original, honest, and accurate work supported by reliable data. Any fabrication or misrepresentation of data is considered a serious ethical violation and is handled under the Research Misconduct policy.

Originality. Manuscripts must be original and not under review or published elsewhere. Proper citation is required for all references. Plagiarism will be checked using plagiarism detection tools, as described on the Plagiarism page.

Duplicate Submission. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously is unethical and may result in permanent rejection. Authors wishing to offer their work elsewhere must first withdraw it, as described on the Withdrawal of Manuscript page.

Authorship. All persons named as authors must have made a substantial contribution to the work and must be accountable for it, and no person meeting those conditions may be omitted. Gift, ghost, and purchased authorship are breaches of publication ethics. The criteria, and the procedure for changing authorship after submission, are set out on the Authorship Criteria page.

Acknowledgment of Sources. Authors must acknowledge all relevant sources and contributions from others, including academic references and technical support.

Conflict of Interest. Authors must disclose any financial or personal conflicts of interest that could influence the outcomes or interpretation of their research. The categories requiring disclosure are set out on the Conflict of Interest page.

Research Involving Human Participants. Where a study involves students, teachers, parents, congregants, or other human participants, authors must report that informed consent was obtained and, where required, that institutional ethical approval was granted. Where participants are minors, the written consent of a parent or guardian is required. Participants must not be identifiable without their consent.

Use of Artificial Intelligence. Generative artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors. Any use of such tools in preparing a manuscript must be disclosed in the declarations, as set out on the AI Policy page.

Revisions and Corrections. If significant errors are discovered after publication, authors are responsible for promptly notifying the editor so that a correction or retraction may be issued, in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy.

For Editors

Publication Decisions. Editors are responsible for deciding which manuscripts will be published, based on peer review results, journal scope, and scholarly merit.

Fairness and Objectivity. Manuscripts must be evaluated on academic content alone, regardless of the authors’ background, ethnicity, gender, religion, denominational or confessional position, nationality, or institutional affiliation.

Confidentiality. Editors and staff must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and must not misuse any information obtained through the editorial process. An unpublished manuscript may not be cited, shared, or drawn upon for an editor’s own work.

Conflicts of Interest. Editors with potential conflicts of interest must recuse themselves from handling the manuscript and assign it to another editor. Where an editor is an author, the submission is handled by an editor who is not involved in the work and who has no access to its editorial record, as set out on the Conflict of Interest page.

Response to Concerns. Editors must take seriously any allegation of misconduct concerning a submitted or published manuscript, examine it under the Research Misconduct policy, and give the authors an opportunity to respond before any conclusion is reached.

Integrity of the Record. Editors are responsible for correcting the published record when an error or breach of integrity is established, through the measures set out on the Correction and Retraction page.

For Reviewers

Contribution to Editorial Decision. Reviewers assist the editorial team by offering objective evaluations and constructive feedback for manuscript improvement.

Objectivity. Reviews must be conducted objectively with clear and supportive reasoning. Personal criticism of the author is not permitted.

Confidentiality. Manuscripts under review are confidential and should not be shared or used for personal gain. Reviewers must not upload a manuscript or any part of it to a generative artificial intelligence tool, and must not delegate the evaluation to such a tool.

Conflicts of Interest. Reviewers must decline to review a manuscript if they have any conflicts of interest due to relationships with the authors or institutions involved.

Promptness. Reviewers who cannot complete a review within the agreed period should inform the editorial office without delay so that a replacement may be appointed.

Alertness to Misconduct. Reviewers who notice substantial similarity to published work, or any other indication of ethical breach, should bring it to the attention of the editors rather than address it in their report to the authors.

For the Publisher

Editorial Independence. The publisher ensures that editorial decisions are made independently, free from commercial or external influences, and does not intervene in the evaluation of individual manuscripts.

Ethical Compliance. The publisher is responsible for ensuring all published articles comply with COPE ethical standards.

Transparency and Integrity. The publisher promotes transparency throughout the editorial and publication process and supports ethical research practices. Ownership, governance, and funding of the journal are disclosed on the Ownership and Management page.

Intellectual Property Rights. The publisher safeguards the copyright and intellectual property rights of authors in accordance with applicable laws. Copyright remains with the authors, under the terms set out on the Copyright and License page.

Preservation of the Record. The publisher is responsible for the continued availability of published content and for the permanence of its identifiers, as set out on the Archive Policy page.

Reporting Concerns

Any person who believes that a manuscript or published article breaches these principles may write to the editorial office. Concerns are examined under the procedure set out on the Research Misconduct policy, in confidence, and by an editor with no involvement in the work concerned.