AI Policy

This policy governs the use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools and technologies in the research, writing, review, and editorial processes for all manuscripts submitted to REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education. Its purpose is to uphold academic integrity, ensure transparency, and promote ethical practice in scholarly communication within the field of Christian education.

For the avoidance of doubt, this policy concerns the use of AI in the preparation and handling of manuscripts. It does not restrict AI as a subject of research. Studies examining artificial intelligence in Christian education are within the scope of this journal and are welcomed.

Guidelines for Authors

a. Use of AI in Research

Authors may use AI tools for data analysis, translation, or other research-related purposes, provided that such use is clearly described in the Methodology section of the manuscript.

Authors must state the name, version, and purpose of the AI tools used, and acknowledge their limitations, assumptions, and potential biases to ensure transparency and reproducibility.

Authors must not submit confidential research material to an external AI tool. This includes interview transcripts, questionnaire responses, classroom recordings, and any other data identifying students, teachers, parents, or congregants. Transmitting such material may breach the consent given by participants or their guardians, irrespective of whether it is subsequently published.

b. Use of AI in Writing

Authors must disclose any use of AI in drafting, editing, paraphrasing, translating, or proofreading the manuscript. This includes tools such as ChatGPT, Grammarly, DeepL, or similar applications.

AI tools may assist in language refinement but must not replace the author’s intellectual contribution. Generating substantial portions of a manuscript and presenting them as the authors’ own composition is not permitted.

All AI-generated or AI-assisted content must be reviewed, verified, and contextualised by the authors to ensure theological soundness, academic accuracy, and ethical integrity.

AI tools must not be used to generate references, citations, or quotations. Every source cited must have been located, read, and verified by the authors in its original form. This applies with particular force to quotations from Scripture, from commentaries, and from classical theological works, where such tools are known to produce plausible but non-existent material.

AI tools must not be used to generate images or figures presented as documentation of actual classrooms, participants, or educational activities.

c. Authorship and AI

AI systems cannot be listed as authors under any circumstances. Authorship is reserved exclusively for individuals who have made substantial intellectual contributions and who are capable of being held accountable for the work, as set out on the Authorship Criteria page.

Authors are fully responsible for all content of the manuscript, including sections that involved AI-assisted work.

d. Ethical Considerations

Authors must ensure that the use of AI complies with ethical standards, including data privacy, informed consent, and institutional ethics guidelines.

AI must not be used to fabricate, falsify, or manipulate data. Any misuse will be treated as academic misconduct and handled under the Research Misconduct policy.

e. Disclosure of AI Use

Where an AI tool has been used in any permitted capacity, the authors must say so in the declarations section placed before the list of references, naming the tool and version and describing the purpose of its use in one or two sentences. A manuscript prepared without such assistance must state that explicitly rather than remaining silent.

AI-generated text is not a citable source, because its output cannot be retrieved or verified by a reader. Such use is recorded in the declarations and is not entered in the list of references.

Disclosure made in good faith is not a ground for rejection. Undisclosed use that is subsequently discovered is treated as a breach of publication ethics.

Guidelines for Reviewers

a. Confidentiality

A manuscript under review is a confidential document and the intellectual property of its authors. Reviewers must not upload a manuscript, or any part of it, to a generative AI tool. This prohibition applies to every purpose, including summarisation, language checking, and translation, because each requires the text to be transmitted outside the review process.

b. Use of AI in Peer Review

Reviewers must not delegate the evaluation of a manuscript to an AI tool. A review report is an expert judgement for which the reviewer is personally accountable.

Reviewers may use such tools to improve the language of a report they have written themselves, provided the report contains no identifying or confidential content at the time.

Any use of AI in connection with a review must be disclosed to the editorial board.

c. Responsibilities and Human Oversight

Peer review must remain a human-led and expertise-driven process. Reviewers must exercise their professional and scholarly discernment, and must ensure that their evaluations remain objective, accurate, and free from algorithmic bias.

Guidelines for Editors

a. AI-Assisted Editorial Processes

Editors are bound by the same restriction on confidentiality as reviewers and must not transmit manuscript content to generative AI tools.

Editors may use AI tools for non-decisional administrative tasks that involve no transmission of manuscript content, such as workflow management. Similarity screening is conducted through the service named on the Plagiarism page.

All editorial and publication decisions must remain under human responsibility and cannot be delegated to AI systems.

b. Disclosure and Transparency

The editorial team will disclose any significant use of AI tools in the editorial process to maintain openness and trust with authors and readers.

Transparency and Disclosure

All stakeholders — authors, reviewers, and editors — must disclose the use of AI tools in their respective roles. Disclosure must include:

  • The type and version of the AI tool used;
  • The purpose and scope of its use; and
  • The extent of its influence on the research or editorial process.

Failure to disclose significant AI usage will be considered a violation of ethical standards and may result in rejection, retraction, or removal from reviewer or editorial duties.

Detection and Enquiries

The journal does not rely on automated AI-detection tools as the sole basis for a finding of undisclosed use, since such tools are known to produce both false positives and false negatives, and to disadvantage authors writing in a second language.

Where the editorial board has reason to question the preparation of a manuscript, it raises the matter with the corresponding author and invites an explanation, together with supporting material such as drafts, data, or original sources, before reaching any conclusion. The procedure followed is that set out on the Research Misconduct page.

Integrity and Accountability

REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education reserves the right to:

  • Request detailed explanations or supporting evidence regarding the use of AI tools in manuscripts or review processes;
  • Conduct investigations and take appropriate action in cases of unethical or undisclosed AI use;
  • Issue a correction or retract a published article where AI misuse or misrepresentation is discovered after publication, in accordance with the Correction and Retraction policy.

Continuous Review

Given the pace of development in this area, this policy is reviewed annually by the editorial board, and any revision is announced through the Announcements section of the journal website. The editorial board welcomes suggestions from authors, reviewers, and readers.