Authorship Criteria

Authorship carries both credit and accountability. REAL DIDACHE: Journal of Christian Education adopts the criteria of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), adapted to the disciplinary character of theological and educational scholarship.

Criteria for authorship

A person named as an author of a manuscript submitted to REAL DIDACHE must satisfy all four of the following conditions.

  • Substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of its data, sources, or arguments
  • Drafting the manuscript or revising it critically for important intellectual content
  • Approval of the version submitted and of any revised version resubmitted after review
  • Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including the integrity and accuracy of any part of it

A person who satisfies the first condition alone is not an author. Conversely, a person who satisfies all four conditions may not be excluded from the list of authors.

Contributions that do not warrant authorship

The following contributions, taken by themselves, do not establish a claim to authorship. They should be recognised in the Acknowledgements section, with the written permission of the person concerned.

  • Holding a position of institutional authority over an author or over the unit in which the research was conducted
  • Supervising a thesis, dissertation, or student project without intellectual involvement in the manuscript itself
  • Providing funding, facilities, access to a school, seminary, or congregation, or administrative support
  • Collecting data under instruction, transcribing interviews, or administering instruments without participating in their design or interpretation
  • Translating, proofreading, or formatting the manuscript
  • Preaching, teaching, or delivering the material on which a manuscript reports, without contributing to its scholarly analysis
  • Granting general encouragement or reading a draft informally

Practices that are not permitted

  • Gift or honorary authorship: naming a person who has not met the criteria, whether out of deference, gratitude, or expectation
  • Ghost authorship: omitting a person who has met the criteria, including a student whose work forms the substance of the manuscript
  • Purchased authorship: acquiring or selling a position in the list of authors, whether through payment or through any brokerage service
  • Duplicated authorship: submitting substantially the same work under different combinations of authors

The editorial board treats any of these practices as a breach of publication ethics and handles it under the Research Misconduct policy.

Students and supervisors

Manuscripts derived from undergraduate, graduate, and doctoral research are welcomed by this journal, and form a significant part of what it publishes. Where such a manuscript is published, the student whose research forms its basis is ordinarily the first author. A supervisor is named as a co-author only where their contribution meets the four criteria above; the supervisory relationship in itself does not establish authorship.

Authorship of such manuscripts should be discussed and agreed between student and supervisor before the manuscript is written, not after it is accepted. Where a manuscript lists a large number of co-authors drawn from a single course or research group, the editors may ask the corresponding author to state the contribution of each.

Order of authors and the corresponding author

The order in which authors are listed is determined by the authors themselves and should reflect the relative weight of their contributions. The journal does not impose an order and does not adjudicate between authors on this matter.

The corresponding author is the single author designated to communicate with the editorial office. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all named authors have approved the submission, for responding to editorial and reviewer correspondence on behalf of all authors, for the accuracy of author names, affiliations, and electronic mail addresses, and for communicating editorial decisions to the other authors. Designation as corresponding author confers no additional academic credit.

Author names and affiliations

Names are published as the authors supply them. Authors are asked to give their name in the form they use consistently across their publications, so that their work can be traced and cited correctly. Where a name is a mononym, it is entered as such and not duplicated.

Affiliation is stated as the institution at which the author was based when the work was carried out. It is given in full, in the institution’s own official form, together with the city and country. Authors who have since moved may add their present affiliation in a note. Authors are encouraged to supply an ORCID identifier.

Statement of author contributions

Every manuscript must include a statement of author contributions, placed before the list of references, specifying what each named author contributed. Where a manuscript has a single author, this is stated as such.

Use of artificial intelligence

Generative artificial intelligence tools cannot be named as authors, since they are incapable of approving a manuscript or of being held accountable for it. Authors who have used such tools in preparing a manuscript must disclose this in the declarations, as set out on the AI Policy page. The authors remain fully responsible for the content of the manuscript, including any material produced with such assistance.

Changes to authorship after submission

Any addition, removal, or reordering of authors after a manuscript has been submitted requires a written request from the corresponding author to the editorial office, stating the reason and confirming that every author, including any to be removed, has agreed in writing. The editorial board does not process such requests after publication except through the formal correction procedure described on the Correction and Retraction page.

Disputes concerning authorship

Where a dispute over authorship is brought to the attention of the editorial board, consideration of the manuscript is suspended until the dispute is resolved. The journal does not arbitrate such disputes, which are matters for the institutions of the parties concerned. The editorial board follows the relevant COPE guidance in determining whether to proceed with, decline, or withdraw the manuscript.

Deceased authors

Where an author dies before publication, the corresponding author informs the editorial office. The name is retained in the list of authors, with a note to that effect, provided the deceased had approved the substance of the manuscript.