Post-Publication Discussion
Publication does not close discussion of an article. A finding may be questioned, an argument contested, a reading of a text disputed, or an interpretation extended. Real Kiddos: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak Usia Dini regards such exchange as proper to scholarship and provides formal channels through which it may take place and be preserved in the published record.
This page concerns scholarly disagreement. Where a reader believes that an article contains an error of fact or a breach of research integrity, the appropriate channels are those described in the Correction and Retraction and Research Misconduct policies.
Channels available
Letter to the editor
A reader may submit a short response to a published article, raising a question, offering a correction of interpretation, contesting a conclusion, or drawing attention to evidence the authors did not consider.
- Length: up to 1,500 words, with a maximum of ten references
- Submitted through the Open Journal Systems platform, identifying the article to which it responds by title and digital object identifier
- Assessed by the editors for relevance, scholarly substance, and tone; not subject to double-blind peer review
- Published in the next available issue, with a digital object identifier, and linked to the original article
Where a letter is accepted, the authors of the original article are informed and invited to reply. A reply is subject to the same limits and is published alongside the letter. Where the authors decline to reply, or do not respond within thirty days, the letter is published alone, with a note to that effect.
Letters are published under the name of their author. The journal does not publish anonymous or pseudonymous responses.
Commentary
Where a published article raises an issue of wider significance for early childhood education, the editorial board may invite a commentary from a scholar or practitioner with relevant expertise. A commentary develops the discussion rather than merely responding to it.
- Length: 2,000 to 3,000 words
- Published by invitation of the editorial board
- Reviewed editorially; the authors of the original article are informed before publication and may submit a reply
Response article
Where a response requires the full apparatus of scholarship — its own argument, method, evidence, and engagement with the literature — it should be submitted as a manuscript in its own right, under the appropriate type described on the Manuscript Types page. Such a manuscript is subject to the ordinary process of double-blind peer review and is assessed on its own merits.
Direct correspondence with authors
The electronic mail address of the corresponding author is published with every article. Readers are free to write directly, and many questions are best resolved this way. Correspondence of this kind is private and does not form part of the published record.
Standards for contributions
Contributions submitted through these channels are expected to meet the following standards.
- The disagreement is with the argument, the evidence, or the method, and not with the person, the institution, or the standing of the authors
- Claims are supported by reference to evidence or scholarship
- The position being criticised is represented accurately and in its strongest form
- The tone is such that a scholarly exchange can continue
The editorial board declines contributions that are gratuitously personal, that misrepresent the work they address, or that pursue a dispute unrelated to the scholarship. A contribution may be returned with an invitation to revise rather than declined outright.
Theological and pedagogical disagreement
This journal publishes work that draws on Christian theological traditions as well as on educational research, and its contributors hold differing confessional and pedagogical commitments. Disagreement of this kind is expected and is not a defect in the journal.
The editorial board does not adjudicate theological disputes and does not decline a contribution on the ground that its position differs from that of the publishing institution or of the editors. What the board requires is that a position be argued, that it engage seriously with the view it opposes, and that it bear on early childhood education rather than remain an exchange on doctrine alone.
Where an exchange has run its course without advancing, the editors may close it, informing the parties that further contributions on the matter will not be published.
Editorial independence in discussion
The editors do not take sides in a disagreement between contributors. The decision to publish a letter, a commentary, or a reply rests on the standards above and not on the position taken. Where a member of the editorial board is party to a discussion, whether as the author of an article under criticism or as the author of a response, that member takes no part in the decision to publish, in accordance with the Conflict of Interest policy.
Permanence
Letters, commentaries, replies, and response articles are published items of the journal. Each carries a digital object identifier, is archived under the same terms as other articles, and is linked to the article it concerns. Once published, such a contribution is not removed, and the discussion remains available to later readers.

