Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest exists where a person involved in the evaluation or publication of a manuscript holds a financial, professional, institutional, or personal interest capable of influencing their judgement, or capable of being reasonably perceived as doing so.

The existence of such an interest is not in itself improper, and declaring one is not an admission of wrongdoing. What compromises the integrity of a journal is not the interest but its concealment. Real Kiddos: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak Usia Dini therefore requires disclosure from authors, reviewers, and editors alike, and manages rather than merely records what is disclosed.

Interests that must be declared

The categories below apply to authors, reviewers, and editors in relation to a particular manuscript.

Financial interests

  • Funding, grants, or sponsorship received for the research reported
  • Employment, consultancy, or paid advisory work with an organisation having an interest in the findings
  • Ownership of, or a commercial stake in, a programme, curriculum, learning method, application, or teaching material evaluated or recommended in the manuscript
  • Royalties, honoraria, or payment in kind connected with the subject of the manuscript

Professional and institutional interests

  • Membership of the editorial board of this journal
  • Employment at, or formal affiliation with, the institution that publishes this journal
  • Current or recent collaboration, co-authorship, or joint research with another party to the manuscript
  • Service as a supervisor, examiner, or mentor to an author
  • Competition for the same funding, position, or academic recognition as an author
  • Leadership or governance of a kindergarten, playgroup, school, foundation, or church programme that is the subject of the manuscript

Personal interests

  • Family relationship, marriage, or close friendship with another party to the manuscript
  • Known personal conflict or estrangement with another party to the manuscript
  • Membership of the same congregation, denomination, or organisation where that membership bears directly on the subject of the manuscript

Obligations of authors

The corresponding author declares, on behalf of all authors, any interest falling within the categories above, using the declarations section of the manuscript. Where there is nothing to declare, this must be stated explicitly rather than left blank.

Where the manuscript evaluates a programme, curriculum, institution, or method in which any author has a stake, that relationship must be described in the body of the manuscript as well, so that readers may weigh the findings accordingly.

A declaration of interest does not prejudice the evaluation of a manuscript. A manuscript is judged on its scholarly merit, and no manuscript is declined on the ground of a declared interest alone.

Obligations of reviewers

A reviewer who holds any interest falling within the categories above declines the invitation to review and informs the editorial office of the reason. A reviewer who recognises such an interest after beginning the review withdraws at that point and returns the manuscript without further comment.

Reviewers who are uncertain whether an interest requires withdrawal should raise the matter with the editor rather than resolve it privately. The judgement belongs to the editor.

Obligations of editors

An editor who holds any interest in relation to a manuscript withdraws from handling it. The manuscript is reassigned to another editor, who conducts the process independently and whose decision is final.

Manuscripts authored by editors. Where a member of the editorial board submits a manuscript, that member has no access to the editorial record of the submission, takes no part in the selection of reviewers, and receives no information about their identity. The submission is handled by an editor who is not a co-author and who has no interest in the work. Where the Editor-in-Chief is an author, the manuscript is handled by another member of the editorial board designated for that purpose.

Manuscripts from the publishing institution. Manuscripts authored by staff or students of Institut Agama Kristen REAL Batam are subject to the same process as all other submissions, and are assigned to reviewers from outside the institution.

Management of declared interests

The editorial board does not treat disclosure as the end of the matter. Depending on the nature of the interest, the editors may take any of the following measures.

  • Publish the declaration with the article, which is the ordinary course
  • Assign additional reviewers from outside the field or institution concerned
  • Require the authors to state the relationship in the body of the article
  • Reassign the manuscript to a different handling editor
  • Decline the manuscript, where the interest is so substantial that no measure can preserve the integrity of the evaluation

Undisclosed interests

Where an interest that ought to have been declared comes to light during the review process, the editorial board suspends consideration of the manuscript and invites the corresponding author to explain. Where such an interest comes to light after publication, the matter is examined under the journal’s Research Misconduct policy, and may result in a published correction or, in a serious case, in retraction.

Declarations by the editorial board

Members of the editorial board of this journal disclose their institutional affiliations on the Editorial Board page. No member of the board receives payment from any commercial party in connection with the editorial work of this journal.

Enquiries

Any person who considers that an undisclosed interest has affected a manuscript or a published article may write to the editorial office. Enquiries are treated in confidence and are examined by an editor who has no involvement in the work concerned.