Withdrawl Policy
This policy governs the withdrawal of a manuscript before it is published. An article that has already been published is not withdrawn; where a published article is found to be unreliable, the record is corrected or the article retracted under the Correction and Retraction policy.
Authors retain the right to withdraw a manuscript from consideration. This journal does not compel the publication of work that its authors no longer wish to publish. At the same time, peer review draws on the unpaid labour of scholars, and a withdrawal at a late stage disrupts the preparation of an issue. The editorial board therefore asks that withdrawal be requested promptly, with reasons, and through the proper channel.
How to request withdrawal
A request is made by the corresponding author, by electronic mail to the editorial office, stating the manuscript title, its submission identifier, and the reason for the request, and confirming that all authors agree to it. The editorial office responds within seven working days. A manuscript is not regarded as withdrawn until the authors receive written confirmation.
Withdrawal at each stage
Before review begins. The request is granted without condition and without charge. The manuscript is marked as withdrawn in the editorial system and the file is removed from active consideration.
During review. The request is granted. The editorial office informs the reviewers that their assessments are no longer required. Authors are asked to withdraw at this stage only where there is good reason, since reviewers have already committed their time.
After acceptance. Acceptance is the point at which the journal has completed its evaluation and has begun to allocate the article to an issue and to commit resources to copyediting, layout, and the registration of a digital object identifier. A request at this stage is granted, but an administrative charge of Rp 300,000 is payable to the publisher as reimbursement of costs already incurred. The withdrawal takes effect once the charge is settled. The charge is waived where the withdrawal arises from an error or a circumstance attributable to the journal, and in other cases where the editorial board considers it warranted.
After an issue has been published. The manuscript is no longer a manuscript, and this policy no longer applies.
Withdrawal at the initiative of the journal
The editorial board may itself withdraw a manuscript from the publication process, at any stage before publication, where it is found to fall outside the scope of the journal, where the authors do not respond to correspondence for sixty days, where a required revision is not received within the agreed period, or where a matter arises that is examined under the Research Misconduct policy. The authors are informed in writing of the reason.
Concurrent submission
A manuscript under consideration by this journal must not be submitted elsewhere. Authors who wish to offer their work to another journal should first withdraw it from this one and await written confirmation. Submitting a manuscript to another journal while it remains under consideration here is treated as a breach of publication ethics, whether or not a withdrawal request has been sent, and is examined under the Research Misconduct policy.
Withdrawal without notice
Where authors cease to respond, or where it emerges that a manuscript has been published elsewhere while under consideration here, the editorial board may decline to accept further submissions from the authors concerned for a period of between one and three years. The decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief and is communicated to the authors in writing, with the grounds stated. The authors may appeal under the procedure set out in the Research Misconduct policy.
Effect of withdrawal
A withdrawn manuscript is not evaluated further and is not published. Copyright remains with the authors throughout, and any assignment of publishing rights made at submission lapses on withdrawal. Reviewer reports already prepared are not released to the authors after a withdrawal at their own request. The editorial office retains the record of the submission for its own administrative purposes, in confidence.

