Correction and Retraction
An article published by Real Kiddos: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak Usia Dini forms part of the permanent scholarly record. Where an error or a breach of integrity is found in a published article, the journal does not remove or quietly amend it. The record is corrected openly, so that readers who have already cited or relied upon the article can see what has changed and why.
This policy follows the retraction guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). It applies to articles that have been published. Manuscripts not yet published are governed by the Withdrawal of Manuscript policy.
Principles
The published version is never altered. The article of record, as originally published, remains available in full. Corrections and retractions are published as separate documents linked to it.
Nothing is removed from the archive. Articles are not deleted from the journal website, and their digital object identifiers remain permanently resolvable.
Notices are open access and citable. Every correction and retraction notice is published in a current issue, carries its own digital object identifier, is freely accessible without charge, and is registered with Crossref and linked to the original article in both directions.
Notices state what changed. A notice identifies the error and its effect on the findings. It does not apportion blame beyond what is necessary, and it is written in terms that are informative rather than accusatory.
Measures available
Correction
A correction is published where an error affects part of an article but the findings and conclusions remain sound. Corrections are issued, for example, where a figure or table has been reproduced incorrectly, where a reference or citation is wrong, where an author’s name or affiliation is in error, where funding or a conflict of interest was omitted from the declarations, or where a calculation is mistaken in a way that does not alter the conclusions.
The notice is published under the title Correction to: [title of the article], stating the original citation, the error, and the corrected text. Where the corrected text would be difficult to follow in isolation, a corrected version of the full article may be published alongside the original, with both versions clearly dated and labelled.
Retraction
A retraction is published where the findings of an article are unreliable, or where the article ought not to have been published. The grounds for retraction are as follows.
- The findings rest on fabricated or falsified data, whether through misconduct or through serious error
- The article contains substantial plagiarism
- The work has been published previously elsewhere without disclosure or justification
- The research was conducted without the consent or ethical approval it required, or in breach of the confidentiality promised to participants
- The authorship is materially misrepresented
- A conflict of interest that was concealed is found to have affected the findings
- An error of such magnitude is found that the conclusions cannot stand
The notice is published under the title Retraction: [title of the article], stating the original citation, the ground for retraction, who requested it, and the date. The original article remains on the website, with a watermark on each page of the file and a statement at the head of the landing page identifying it as retracted and linking to the notice.
A retraction concerns the reliability of the published work. It is not in itself a finding against the authors, and an article may be retracted at the request of its own authors where they discover a serious error in their own work. Such a retraction is stated to be at the authors’ initiative, and the editorial board regards it as the conduct of responsible scholars.
Partial retraction
Where a defined and separable part of an article is unreliable while the remainder stands, a partial retraction may be published, identifying precisely which findings are withdrawn.
Expression of concern
An expression of concern is published where the editorial board has substantial grounds to doubt the reliability of an article but is not yet in a position to conclude the matter, for example where an institutional enquiry is in progress or where the authors do not respond. The notice states the nature of the concern and that the matter remains under examination. It is replaced by a correction, a retraction, or a notice of resolution once the matter is concluded.
Removal
Removal of an article is reserved for the rare case in which the article itself is unlawful, defames an identifiable person, or constitutes a serious infringement of the privacy of a research participant, such that its continued availability would cause harm. In such a case the metadata, the title, and the names of the authors remain on the website, together with a statement of the reason for removal. Removal requires the approval of the Editor-in-Chief and of the publishing institution. The editorial board does not remove an article at the request of an author or of a third party on any other ground.
How a matter is raised and decided
Authors who discover an error in their own published article should notify the editorial office without delay. Readers who have reason to doubt a published article may write to the editorial office, enclosing the grounds for their concern.
Where the matter involves a possible breach of integrity, it is examined under the Research Misconduct policy, and the authors are given an opportunity to respond before any measure is taken. Where it is a matter of straightforward error, the editors verify it with the authors and issue a correction.
The decision to correct, retract, or publish an expression of concern rests with the Editor-in-Chief, acting on the advice of the editorial board. The editors endeavour to obtain the agreement of the authors, but a notice may be published without their agreement where it is necessary to correct the record. Where the authors disagree with a retraction, their dissent is recorded in the notice.
Notification
When a notice is published, the editorial office informs the authors, the person who raised the matter, the indexing services in which the journal is listed, and, where the article has been widely cited, such other parties as may need to know.
Appeal
An author who disputes a decision to correct or retract may appeal in writing to the Editor-in-Chief within thirty days, on the grounds and under the procedure set out in the Research Misconduct policy. A retraction notice remains in place while an appeal is considered, and is amended or withdrawn if the appeal succeeds.

