Artificial Intelligence Policy
Real Kiddos: Jurnal Pendidikan Anak Usia Dini recognises that generative artificial intelligence tools are now widely available to authors, reviewers, and editors. This policy states the conditions under which such tools may be used in connection with manuscripts submitted to or published by this journal. It follows the position statement of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) on authorship and artificial intelligence tools.
For the avoidance of doubt, this policy concerns the use of artificial intelligence in the preparation and handling of manuscripts. It does not restrict artificial intelligence as a subject of research. Studies examining artificial intelligence in early childhood education are within the scope of this journal and are welcomed.
Use by authors
Authors remain fully and solely responsible for every part of a manuscript bearing their names, including any portion prepared with the assistance of an artificial intelligence tool. Responsibility cannot be transferred to a tool, to its developer, or to any service that employs it.
Uses that are permitted, subject to disclosure:
- Improving the clarity, grammar, or readability of text written by the authors
- Translating text written by the authors between Bahasa Indonesia and English
- Assisting with the formatting of references
- Supporting the exploration of literature, provided that every source cited has been located, read, and verified by the authors in its original form
Uses that are not permitted:
- Generating substantial portions of the manuscript and presenting them as the authors’ own composition
- Producing, altering, or augmenting research data, interview transcripts, observational records, or statistical results
- Generating references, citations, or quotations, including direct quotations from Scripture or from scholarly works
- Generating images, figures, or diagrams presented as documentation of actual educational settings, children’s work, or research activity
- Submitting a manuscript to an artificial intelligence tool where doing so would expose confidential information about children, parents, teachers, or institutions participating in the research
The last point requires particular attention in this journal. Research in early childhood education commonly involves data concerning minors. Transmitting such material to an external tool may constitute a breach of the consent given by parents or guardians, irrespective of whether the material is subsequently published.
Disclosure
Where an artificial intelligence tool has been used in any permitted capacity, the authors must say so in the declarations section of the manuscript, naming the tool and version and describing the purpose of its use in one or two sentences. A manuscript prepared without such assistance must state that explicitly rather than remaining silent.
Disclosure made in good faith is not a ground for rejection. Undisclosed use that is subsequently discovered is treated as a breach of publication ethics and handled under the journal’s Research Misconduct policy.
Use by reviewers
Reviewers must not upload a manuscript under review, or any part of it, to a generative artificial intelligence tool. A manuscript submitted to this journal is a confidential document, and transmitting it to an external system breaches that confidentiality and may compromise the intellectual property of the authors.
Reviewers must not delegate the evaluation of a manuscript to an artificial intelligence tool. A review report is an expert judgement for which the reviewer is personally accountable. Reviewers may use such tools to improve the language of a report they have written themselves, provided the report contains no identifying or confidential content at the time.
Use by editors
Editors are bound by the same restriction on confidentiality as reviewers. Editorial decisions are made by the editors on the basis of the manuscript and the review reports, and are not generated or determined by artificial intelligence tools. Such tools may be used for administrative purposes that involve no transmission of manuscript content.
Detection and enquiries
The journal does not rely on automated detection tools as the sole basis for a finding of undisclosed use, since such tools are known to produce both false positives and false negatives. Where the editorial board has reason to question the preparation of a manuscript, it raises the matter with the corresponding author and invites an explanation, together with supporting material such as drafts, data, or original sources, before reaching any conclusion.
Review of this policy
Given the pace of development in this area, the editorial board reviews this policy annually and announces any revision through the Announcements section of the journal website.

