AI Policy

THECRED: Proceedings of The Theology Conference and Religious Education Dialogue recognises that generative artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies now form part of the scholarly workflow. This policy sets out the conditions under which such tools may be used by authors, reviewers, and editors. It follows the positions of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). It applies to all manuscripts submitted to, under review by, or published in THECRED, including conference papers accepted for publication in the proceedings.

As a proceedings in theology and religious education, THECRED holds that scholarly authorship is an act of personal and moral responsibility. Tools may assist human judgement; they cannot assume it. Accountability for every claim, citation, and interpretation published here rests with named human authors.

1. AI Cannot Be an Author

Generative AI tools do not satisfy the criteria for authorship. They cannot take responsibility for the integrity of a work, cannot approve a final version, cannot declare conflicts of interest, and cannot respond to post-publication queries or corrections. Accordingly, AI tools must not be listed as an author or co-author, and must not be credited in the author line, the corresponding author field, or the author contribution statement. Where a tool has been used, it is acknowledged under Section 4 of this policy, not credited as a contributor.

2. Permitted Use by Authors

Subject to disclosure, authors may use AI-assisted tools for:

a. language editing, grammar correction, spelling, and improvement of readability, provided the scholarly content and argument are the authors’ own;
b. translation of text authored by the researchers, provided the authors verify that theological, biblical, and technical terminology has been rendered accurately;
c. formatting of references and manuscript layout, provided every reference is independently verified against the original source;
d. preliminary literature searching and identification of sources, provided each source is located, read, and cited from the original publication;
e. basic assistance with coding or data processing, provided the procedure and its results are verified by the authors.

In every case, the authors must review the output and remain fully responsible for it. Use of AI for these purposes does not transfer any part of the authors’ responsibility to the tool or its developer.

3. Restricted and Prohibited Use

Authors must not use AI-assisted tools to:

a. generate the substantive scholarly content of a manuscript, including the argument, analysis, theological interpretation, exegesis, findings, discussion, or conclusion;
b. fabricate, alter, or simulate research data, interview material, informants, field observations, survey results, or any other empirical evidence;
c. generate references, citations, quotations, or page numbers that have not been verified against the original sources, including biblical and patristic citations;
d. generate or manipulate images, figures, diagrams, or tables in a manner that misrepresents the research, except where AI-generated imagery is itself the declared object of study;
e. produce text that misrepresents the extent of the authors’ own intellectual contribution, or that would constitute plagiarism if produced by a human.

Fabricated references and fabricated data are treated as research misconduct under Section 8, regardless of whether an AI tool was involved.

4. Mandatory Disclosure

Authors who have used AI-assisted tools at any stage of the research or writing process must declare this in a statement placed before the Reference list, under the heading “Declaration of Generative AI Use.” The statement must name the tool and version, describe the specific purpose of use, and affirm the authors’ responsibility for the final text.

The following wording may be used:

“During the preparation of this manuscript, the author(s) used [name and version of the tool] for [specific purpose]. After using this tool, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.”

Where no AI tool has been used, authors are encouraged to state: “The author(s) declare that no generative AI tool was used in the preparation of this manuscript.”

Disclosure is required at submission. An undisclosed use discovered after publication will be addressed under Section 8. Use of AI confined to basic spelling and grammar checking integrated into standard word-processing software does not require disclosure.

5. Author Responsibility

Authors bear full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the submitted work, including any portion produced with the assistance of AI. Authors are responsible for verifying that no fabricated reference, misattributed quotation, false biblical citation, or invented data has entered the manuscript. Authors are likewise responsible for ensuring that the use of AI has not introduced plagiarised material or infringed the rights of third parties. Reliance on an AI tool is not a defence against a finding of error or misconduct.

6. Reviewers

Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not upload a manuscript, any portion of it, or any supplementary material into a generative AI tool, since doing so may breach the confidentiality and proprietary rights of the authors and may expose unpublished work to third-party storage or training.

Peer review requires critical judgement that cannot be delegated. Reviewers must not use AI to generate their review report. Reviewers may use AI-assisted tools to improve the language of a report they have themselves written, provided no confidential content from the manuscript is entered into the tool. Any use of AI in the review process must be disclosed to the editor.

7. Editors

Editors are bound by the same confidentiality obligations. Editorial staff must not upload submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, or correspondence into generative AI tools, and must not delegate editorial decisions to such tools. Editorial judgement on acceptance, revision, or rejection remains a human responsibility.

Where AI-assisted tools are used in administrative or technical processes, such as similarity screening or language checking, this use must not compromise the confidentiality of the submission.

8. Screening, Investigation, and Sanctions

All submissions are screened for similarity before acceptance. THECRED may additionally use AI-detection tools; the editorial board treats the output of such tools as supporting indication only and never as sole or conclusive evidence. Where concerns arise, the editor will raise them with the corresponding author and allow a reasonable opportunity to respond before any decision is taken, in accordance with COPE guidance.

Where undisclosed or prohibited use of AI is established, the editorial board may, in proportion to the severity of the case: require revision and proper disclosure; reject the manuscript; retract or correct a published article; notify the authors’ institution; and decline future submissions from the authors concerned.

9. Basis and Review of This Policy

This policy is based on the COPE position statement on authorship and AI tools, the WAME recommendations on chatbots and generative AI, the ICMJE recommendations concerning the use of AI-assisted technology, and the publication ethics framework applied across all journals published by Institut Agama Kristen (IAK) REAL Batam.

Given the pace of technological development, this policy is reviewed periodically and may be revised without prior notice. Authors are advised to consult the version current at the time of submission.